Yucatán relleno negro, with chicken and egg-stuffed pork served in black recado broth
Prep45 min
Cook1 hr 20 min
Serves4 servings
CuisineMexican / Yucatecan

Relleno Negro: Yucatán Black Recado Stew with Egg-Stuffed Pork

How to make relleno negro, the Yucatán black recado stew: chicken, a ground pork but with boiled egg, achiote, a black sauce that is not scorched, substitute ingredients, internal temperatures, storage, how it differs from chilmole, a home version for days without black recado, causes of failure, menus and an FAQ.

Total: 2 hr 5 minLevel: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 10

Work salt and lime into the chicken

8 min + 15 min resting

Working lime, salt, black pepper and black recado into the chicken
Season the chicken with salt and acidity before it goes into the black broth. A moist surface is enough

Cut any large pieces of 2 lb (900 g) chicken to about 2 inches (5 cm) and blot the moisture with paper. Rub in 1 1/4 tsp salt, 1 tbsp lime juice and 1/2 tsp black pepper all over, and rest in the refrigerator for 15 minutes. No heat is used in this step. The surface should feel slightly firm and still smell of lime. If using bone-in meat, remove any blood clots near the bones.

STEP 22 / 10

Mix the but meat mixture

12 min

Mixing ground pork, chopped egg whites, tomato, aromatics and black recado to make the meat mixture for the but
But is a pork stuffing mixed with egg and black recado. If it stays watery, make up the cohesion with potato starch

Separate 2 of the 4 boiled eggs into white and yolk. Chop only the whites into 0.25 inch (5 mm) dice, and set the 2 yolks aside for the center. In a bowl, put 1 lb (450 g) ground pork, the chopped whites, 5.5 oz (150 g) tomato, 3.25 oz (90 g) onion, the garlic, epazote, 1 raw egg, 1 tbsp black recado, 2/3 tsp salt, 1/4 tsp black pepper and 1 tbsp potato starch. Mix for about 1 minute, until sticky and no watery liquid remains at the bottom of the bowl.

STEP 33 / 10

Wrap the yolks and tie in cheesecloth

10 min

Shaping the pork stuffing into a log on a cloth and wrapping the egg yolks
Wrapping the yolks at the center and supporting with the cloth keeps the shape from collapsing even in the black broth

Spread a damp, wrung-out cloth on a cutting board. Press the meat mixture into an oval about 7 inches (18 cm) long. Line up the 2 boiled egg yolks in the center, wrap the meat around them, and shape a thick log. Roll it in the cloth and tie both ends with kitchen twine. The log doesn't have to be a perfect cylinder. Keep the meat at least 1 inch (2 cm) thick all around. If the yolks are exposed, they fall apart in the broth.

STEP 44 / 10

Dissolve the black recado in lukewarm water

6 min

Dissolving black recado in lukewarm water into a thick black sauce
Don't put the black recado straight into the pot; dissolve it first in lukewarm water. This prevents scorching and lumps

With 1.75 oz (50 g) black recado, add ¾ cup (180 ml) lukewarm water (60 to 70°C) a little at a time, and thin it to a thick sauce. On days using the substitute paste, mix the achiote, allspice, cumin, oregano, black pepper, clove, unsweetened cocoa, soy sauce, vinegar and lukewarm water. No heat is used in this step. Lumps scorch on the bottom of the pot, so crush them with the back of a spoon until the sauce falls heavily from a wooden spoon.

STEP 55 / 10

Brown the chicken and pour in the black broth

15 min

Pouring the black recado broth over browned chicken and aromatics
Warm the black broth slowly over medium heat so the black recado does not stick to the bottom

Heat 1 tbsp oil in a heavy pot over medium-high heat for 1 minute. Add the chicken skin side down and brown 3 minutes per side to a light color. It doesn't need to cook through. Add the onion, garlic and tomatoes and cook 4 minutes over medium heat. When the onion turns translucent, add the dissolved black recado, 3¾ cups (900 ml) water or unsalted chicken stock, and the bay leaf. Trace the bottom of the pot with a wooden spoon, and warm over medium heat until small bubbles appear.

STEP 66 / 10

Add the but and simmer over low heat

35 min

Simmering the cloth-wrapped but and chicken over low heat in black recado broth
Simmer the but quietly over low heat. Boiling the black broth hard tends to toughen the meat

When the broth comes to a quiet boil, set the cloth-wrapped but in the center of the pot. If using habanero, add the half whole. Set the lid slightly ajar. Keep the temperature at 85 to 95°C, on low to medium-low heat, and cook for 30 minutes. The surface should tremble quietly, with a small bubble rising about once every 2 seconds. Twice during this, gently trace the bottom of the pot with a wooden spoon. Boiling hard breaks the but and toughens the chicken.

STEP 77 / 10

Add the tomato and onion finishing aromatics

10 min

Briefly warming tomato and onion to make finishing aromatics to return to the black broth
Keep the finishing aromatics short over medium heat. They add the tomato's acidity to the weight of the black sauce

In a separate small pot or frying pan, take 2 tbsp of the broth and add 2.75 oz (80 g) tomato cut in thin strips, 2 oz (60 g) thinly sliced onion and a little cilantro or epazote. Warm over medium heat for 5 minutes, until the tomato corners are rounded and the onion is wilted. Return this to the main pot and let it blend over low heat for 5 more minutes. At home, adding them at the end keeps the black broth from getting too heavy.

STEP 88 / 10

Adjust the thickness of the broth

8 min

Adjusting the thickness of the black recado broth with a little dissolved potato starch and a wooden spoon
Keep the thickening light. Black recado broth tends to scorch if made too thick

If the broth is too thin, dissolve 1 tsp potato starch in 2 tsp water and add only half to the pot. Warm over low heat for 2 minutes, until the broth is lightly thick. A line drawn on the bottom with a wooden spoon should fill back in at once. Don't make it too thick, or the black recado settles on the bottom of the pot. Keep it thin if you'll pour it over white rice, and a little heavier if you'll scoop it with tortillas. Add salt at the end, 1/6 tsp at a time.

STEP 99 / 10

Check the internal temperature

5 min

Taking the but simmered in black recado out and checking its center temperature with a cooking thermometer
Stop the pork stuffing by its center temperature. Do not judge doneness by the darkness of the color

Take the but out of the pot and insert a thermometer into the center through the cloth. At 160°F (71°C) or above at the center, it is cooked. For the chicken, check 165°F (74°C) at a thick part not touching bone. Without a thermometer, cut the end of the but into a half-moon about 0.5 inches (1 cm) thick. No red raw meat should remain at the center, and the juices should run close to clear. If not, return the cloth and cook 5 more minutes over low heat, then check again.

STEP 1010 / 10

Slice the but and plate

8 min

Slicing the cooked but and checking the cross-section of the egg yolk and the black recado sauce
Rest the but a little before slicing. The yellow of the yolk in the black broth is the showpiece of the table

Rest the but for 5 minutes, remove the cloth, and slice it 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) thick. In a deep bowl, put 1 to 2 pieces of chicken, 2 slices of but and the reserved boiled eggs, cut in half. Pour in the black broth until it reaches 80% of the height of the ingredients. Scatter a little cilantro or epazote over the top. Serve with corn tortillas, white rice and lime. For more heat, add a few drops of habanero sauce at the table.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Chicken and the black broth

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bone-in chicken thighs or drumettes 2 lb (900 g) Turkey, same amount. Boneless thighs: 1.75 lb (750 g), with a shorter simmer
Salt 1 1/4 tsp To season the chicken
Lime juice 1 tbsp Or 2 tsp lemon juice
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Coarsely ground
Onion 1, 6.5 oz (180 g) 0.5 inches (1 cm) dice
Tomatoes 2, 10.5 oz (300 g) 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) dice. Canned diced tomatoes: 7 oz (200 g)
Garlic 3 cloves, 15 g Minced
Epazote 5 g No epazote? Use 5 g cilantro stems and 1/4 tsp dried oregano
Black recado 1.75 oz (50 g) Store-bought. For a hot type, start with 1.25 oz (35 g)
Lukewarm water ¾ cup (180 ml) To dissolve the black recado
Water or unsalted chicken stock 3¾ cups (900 ml) Enough to cover the chicken to 70%
Oil 1 tbsp For searing the chicken
Bay leaf 1 Optional
Habanero 1/2 Add whole for aroma only. Leave out for less heat
Lime 1/2 For finishing
2 / 3

Substitute paste for days without black recado

Ingredient Amount Role
Achiote powder, or achiote seeds ground to powder 2 tsp Color and earthy aroma
Allspice powder 1 tsp The warm aroma of Yucatán and the Caribbean side
Ground cumin 1 tsp Earthiness
Dried oregano 1 tsp Herbal feel
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Heat and aroma
Clove powder a pinch Too much tastes medicinal
Unsweetened cocoa powder 1 tsp Blackness and bitterness. Don't use sweetened drinking cocoa
Dark soy sauce 1 tbsp Color and saltiness
Rice vinegar or apple cider vinegar 2 tsp Adds the sour edge of the recado
Lukewarm water ½ cup (150 ml) 60 to 70°C
3 / 3

But: egg-filled pork stuffing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Ground pork 1 lb (450 g) Mixed beef and pork also works. Only ground chicken tends to firm up
Boiled eggs 4 2 with the whites chopped and the yolks used at the center of the stuffing. The other 2 for serving
Raw egg 1 As binder
Tomato 1, 5.5 oz (150 g) Lightly seeded, 0.25 inch (5 mm) dice
Onion 1/2, 3.25 oz (90 g) Minced
Garlic 1 clove, 5 g Grated
Epazote or cilantro 5 g Minced
Black recado or substitute paste 1 tbsp To put a black aroma into the meat
Achiote powder 1/2 tsp May be omitted on days when you use the substitute paste
Salt 2/3 tsp For the ground meat
Black pepper 1/4 tsp For the ground meat
Potato starch 1 tbsp Helps it hold together. A home insurance, not a local ingredient
Clean cheesecloth or muslin 1 piece, 12 inches (30 cm) square To wrap the meatball and keep it from falling apart
Kitchen twine 23.5 inches (60 cm) To tie the cloth
0 / 0

The ink-black broth comes as a surprise when you lift the lid. Then you cut into the pork stuffing, and a yellow yolk shows against the dark liquid, while a slow aroma of spices rises from the bowl. Relleno negro comes from the Yucatán Peninsula in Mexico. It is chicken stewed with tomato and onion in black recado, served with a large egg-filled pork meatball. It tastes of smoke, gentle bitterness and earth more than heat.

About relleno negro

Locally, relleno negro is often made with turkey. At home, bone-in chicken thighs or drumettes are easier to handle and easier to check for doneness. The black color comes from recado negro, also called chilmole, a seasoning paste of charred chilies, achiote, pepper, cumin, oregano, garlic and more. That mix of smoke, bitterness and earthiness is why the dish is not simply hot.

At a Yucatán table it arrives in a deep bowl, and you eat the turkey or chicken, the but, the egg and the black broth together. A tortilla picks up the filling and scoops the broth, and some people pour it over white rice. Break the yolk a little into the black soup. It looks bold, but the way of eating is homely.

Sorting out the names

In Spanish it is Relleno Negro. In the Yucatec Maya context it is sometimes called boox but', meaning a black stuffing or black meatball. The stuffing itself is called but.

Relleno negro and chimole

Dishes made with black recado share names and forms across Yucatán, Belize and Guatemala, so chilmole, chimole, Relleno Negro and Black Dinna sometimes appear side by side. Belize's chimole (in Japanese) is a home dish, close to a black chicken soup. Relleno negro adds the pork-and-egg stuffing, which makes it denser and more festive.

What to look at Relleno negro Chimole
Main region Yucatán Peninsula, Mexico Belize and the Caribbean side
Local names Relleno Negro, boox but', close to chilmole Chimole, Chirmole, Black Dinna
Center of the dish Chicken or turkey stewed in black recado, with an egg-filled but A chicken soup stewed in black recado
Meat stuffing Ground pork, egg and aromatics bound together Added in some homes; often left out of the soup type
Hard part at home The internal temperature of the but, and not scorching the black recado Getting black recado, and not scorching the black broth

Relleno negro layers chicken, black recado, pork stuffing and egg on one plate, with the black broth holding the meats together. Once you see that, the order of work is clear. For the contrast with central Mexico's sauce cultures, try mole poblano, which layers chilies and seeds, and tamales (in Japanese), wrapped in corn husks.

Ingredients (serves 4)

Chicken, ground pork, eggs, black recado, achiote, chilies and aromatics laid out as the ingredients for relleno negro
Separating the black recado, chicken, ground pork, eggs and aromatics beforehand keeps the sequence of simmering and stuffing from falling apart

Turkey is closer to the local version, but it is hard to cook through in a home pot and hard to find. This recipe uses bone-in chicken thighs or drumettes. Shape the ground pork but separately, then simmer it in the same pot. On days without black recado, make the black base with the substitute paste. Don't try to char chilies black.

Allergy and food-poisoning prevention

This dish contains chicken, pork, eggs and soy. Cook the ground pork but through to the center. With a thermometer, confirm 160°F (71°C) or above at the center. Chicken needs 165°F (74°C) at the center. Don't leave the stuffing mixed with raw egg at room temperature for long. Shape it, then move on to simmering right away.

Choosing black recado and other ingredients

Black recado, achiote, dried chilies, a mortar and a cooking thermometer laid out in a kitchen as shopping supplies
Worth looking for specially: achiote to stand in for black recado, a mortar to crush the spices, and a thermometer to check how cooked the meat is

The chicken, ground pork, eggs, onion and tomatoes are easy to find nearby. Black recado is the one to hunt for, since its supply outside Mexico is inconsistent. Buy it whenever you can. Its charred chili and spice aroma can't be fully replaced, but a home paste of achiote, allspice, cumin, oregano and a little unsweetened cocoa steers the flavor in the same direction.

Don't char chilies black in your own kitchen. It makes harsh smoke quickly, and a range hood alone won't protect you. Use store-bought paste or the substitute paste, and add extra heat and bitterness at the table.

Achiote doesn't make the dish black, but it gives the aroma at the base of recado-style dishes from Yucatán and Central America. For the substitute paste, crush achiote seeds, black pepper and oregano coarsely in a mortar to bring out their aroma. It takes more work than mixing powders, but the paste is less gritty and dissolves into the soup more easily. You'll reach for the jar again in tamales (in Japanese) and tacos al pastor, so it gets used up quickly.

Chicken and ground pork cook in the same pot, so a thermometer earns its place. Check the center of the stuffing and the chicken near the bone.

Method: layer the black aroma without scorching it

The steps look like a lot, but the order is simple. Season the chicken. Make the pork but. Dissolve the black recado. Brown the chicken and aromatics, then stew slowly in the black broth. Slice the stuffing and serve. Going slowly keeps the black sauce from turning rough.

Where relleno negro goes wrong

Smooth black recado broth compared with scorched, gritty broth
Failures with relleno negro tend to show up as scorched black recado, a but that falls apart, and under-cooking

The dark color hides the warning signs: the broth looks black whether it is cooked or scorched. Judge instead by aroma, how the bubbles rise, temperature and the cut cross-section. A light bitterness belongs in the dish; a scorched one that comes to the front does not. To prevent it, dissolve the black recado in lukewarm water, don't boil it hard, and work from low to medium-low heat.

Problem Cause How to fix
Strong bitterness The black recado scorched on the bottom of the pot Don't scrape the scorch; move the broth to another pot and thin with ½ cup (100 ml) water and 1 tsp lime juice
The but broke Boiled over high heat, or the meat mixture was watery Next time keep low heat at 85 to 95°C. This time return the crumbled meat to the broth and thicken it slightly
The center is red The but is thick, or not simmered long enough Return it in the cloth, cook 5 to 8 more minutes over low heat, and check the center temperature again
The chicken is tough Boiled long, or boneless meat was cooked for the same time With boneless, check step 6 at 20 minutes. This time, eat with plenty of broth spooned over
The color is pale Too little black recado, or the substitute paste's color is weak Dissolve 2 tsp more black recado, or 1/2 tsp achiote, in a separate dish before adding
Too hot The habanero broke, or the black recado is a hot type Remove the habanero and add ½ cup (100 ml) water, 1/2 tomato and 1 boiled egg, and simmer 10 minutes over low heat

Serving and storing relleno negro

What to serve with it

Menu A day it suits How to pair
Relleno negro, corn tortillas, lime A holiday Yucatecan menu Take up a little of the but and chicken at a time with tortillas
Relleno negro, white rice, cucumber dressed with lime A dinner easy to make at home Spoon the black broth over rice and cut it with a sour side
Relleno negro, tamales (in Japanese), tomato salad A day to line up Mexican dishes Compare the corn dough with the black broth
Relleno negro, a little chimole (in Japanese), lime A day to compare black recados Compare the same black stews with and without the stuffing

For a home dinner, white rice is the staple. The broth is strong, so rather than piling the rice up like a donburi, tuck a little at the edge of the bowl to soak up the broth. If you buy tortillas, choose corn over wheat; corn ties in with the charred aroma of the black recado.

Skip rich cheese dishes on the side. Small, cooling things work better: cucumber squeezed with lime, thinly sliced onion, tomato and chopped cilantro keep the meal from feeling heavy to the end. And if you want to keep exploring how corn, chilies and meat connect, try a big-pot soup like pozole rojo (in Japanese) or tlayuda (in Japanese), where a toasted tortilla holds the toppings.

Storage and reheating

Relleno negro broth, but and boiled eggs divided into shallow storage containers
It contains chicken, but and eggs, so cool it quickly in shallow containers, and store the eggs separately so they are not overheated

Relleno negro contains chicken, ground pork and eggs, so cool it quickly once the heat is off. Put the chicken and broth in separate shallow containers and store the but uncut in another. Eggs harden on reheating, so combine them with broth only for what you'll eat the next day, and finish them the same day or the next.

Refrigerate for up to 2 days. To freeze, portion only the chicken, broth and but, without eggs; they keep 3 weeks in the freezer. To reheat, put 1 portion and 2 tbsp water in a small pot and warm over low heat for 6 to 8 minutes, until the edge of the broth bubbles and the chicken is hot through to the center. Boiling hard toughens both the chicken and the but. In the microwave, heat at 600 W for 2 minutes, stir once, then add 1 more minute. Warm the eggs briefly, then cut in half.

The next day, the black recado aroma has soaked into the meat and the edges are softer than on the first day. If the broth has thickened too much, add 3.5 tbsp (50 ml) water and cook 5 minutes over low heat. If it tastes too salty, a few drops of lime cut the heaviness.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it without black recado?

You can, though it will be relleno negro style rather than the real thing. The substitute paste points the flavor in the same direction with achiote, allspice, cumin, oregano, and a little bitterness and acidity. If you like the result, look for black recado next.

Is chicken instead of turkey fine?

At home, chicken works well. Turkey is closer to the local version, but outside Mexico it is hard to find and hard to fit in a home pot. Bone-in thighs or drumettes bring savoriness to the broth. If you use boneless thighs, check once at about 20 minutes into the simmer in step 6.

Can I make it with just chicken, without the but?

You can, but then it becomes a black chicken stew close to chimole. If the full version feels like too much work the first time, divide the but into 4 small meatballs and serve the boiled eggs separately.

How hot is it?

Heat depends on the black recado. It is not as fiery as it looks, but a hot paste or a habanero makes it strong fast. When the whole family eats, leave the habanero out of the pot and add pepper sauce at the table, so each bowl can be adjusted.