Calçotada: charred long onions, peeled white cores and an orange sauce on a plate
Prep35 min
Cook38 min
Serves4 servings
CuisineSpanish (Catalan)

Calçotada: Catalonia's Charred Spring Onion Feast with Salvitxada

Calçotada is a winter-to-spring Catalan meal of long onions charred black and eaten with a salvitxada-style sauce. How much to char them, how to peel them, a romesco-style sauce, what to look for when shopping, and storage, with concrete cues for cooking under a broiler or on a griddle when you have no outdoor charcoal.

Total: 1 hr 13 minLevel: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 7

Wash and trim the onions

10 min

Cutting off the roots of the long onions and trimming them to leave the white part long
Cut the roots off thinly, and wipe the surface dry before cooking

No heat is used. Cut a thin slice off the roots of the long onions and peel away only the one dirty outer layer. Green leaf tips scorch too easily, so trim them to a total length of about 25 cm to 12 inches (30 cm), leaving some of the soft green part above the white. After washing off the soil, wipe the water off with a cloth before cooking. If they are wet, steam comes out before browning and the outer skin does not blacken as well.

STEP 22 / 7

Roast the tomatoes and garlic

15 min

Roasting tomatoes and unpeeled garlic at high heat and rehydrating a dried pepper
Roast hard until the tomato skins burst and the garlic is soft

Preheat a broiler on high, or an oven to 425°F (220°C). Remove the tomato cores and set the tomatoes and the unpeeled garlic on a small heatproof dish or baking sheet. Under a broiler on high, roast for 10 to 12 minutes; in an oven at 425°F (220°C), 15 minutes, until the tomato skins puff and blacken in places and the garlic is soft when pressed. If using dried ñora pepper, soak it in lukewarm water for 10 minutes, remove the seeds, and scrape off only the flesh.

STEP 33 / 7

Toast the nuts and bread

5 min

Lightly toasting almonds, hazelnuts and torn bread in a skillet
Bring out the aroma of the nuts and bread over medium-low heat, without scorching

Warm a small skillet over medium-low heat for 1 minute and add the almonds, hazelnuts and torn bread. Use no oil, and toast, moving them with a wooden spatula, for 3 to 4 minutes. Turn off the heat when the bread's edges turn a pale golden brown and the surface of the nuts shows a light toasted color. If scorched black, the whole sauce turns bitter, so stop when the aroma rises.

STEP 44 / 7

Blend the sauce coarse

8 min

Making a coarse sauce of roasted tomato, garlic, nuts and bread in a small food processor
Don't make the sauce too smooth; leave grains of nut and bread

No heat is used. Peel the skins off the roasted tomatoes and squeeze the garlic out of its skin. Put the tomato, garlic, nuts, bread, the ñora flesh or smoked paprika, vinegar, 1/2 tsp salt and half the olive oil in a food processor, and run in 20-second bursts. Add the remaining olive oil bit by bit and, if needed, 2 to 4 tbsp water. Stop at a thickness where fine grains of nut and bread remain on the tongue, not a complete mayonnaise-like texture, and finally adjust the salt and vinegar.

STEP 55 / 7

Char the onion skins black

18 min

Cooking long onions on a griddle until the outer skin is charred black
Char the skin black and cook until it gives slightly when pressed with tongs

Start with a broiler on high, an oven at 450°F (230°C), or a griddle over medium-high heat. Under a broiler, arrange the onions on the rack and cook 7 to 8 minutes on one side, then turn and cook 6 to 8 minutes. In the oven, arrange them on a baking sheet and cook at 450°F (230°C) for 16 to 18 minutes, turning once partway. On a griddle, brush with a thin film of oil and cook over medium-high heat, rolling them, for 12 to 15 minutes. The guide is an outer skin that is black and cracked, and a white part that gives slightly when pressed with tongs. To make the inside tender, check the feel when pressed as well as the char color.

STEP 66 / 7

Wrap and carry through with residual heat

10 min

Wrapping the blackened long onions in parchment and foil to rest
Wrapping and resting after cooking makes the white core sweet and tender all the way through

Take the onions off the heat, wrap them in parchment paper, and cover lightly with aluminum foil. Keep them away from direct flame and leave for 10 minutes. The steam inside makes the white core still more tender and the burnt outer skin easier to peel. If wrapped too tightly, water droplets collect, so wrap loosely enough that the steam does not escape too much. They are ready when, on opening, the white part looks translucent and gives off a sweet aroma.

STEP 77 / 7

Peel and dip in the sauce

7 min

Peeling the outer skin of a blackened long onion and setting the white core beside the sauce
Remove the burnt outer skin and dip only the white core in the sauce

No heat is used. Hold the root end of the onion and pull off one or two layers of burnt outer skin. You do not eat the black skin; you eat the soft white part inside. Put plenty of sauce on a plate and dip the onions in one at a time. Eaten while the white core is hot, the sweetness is strong; once cool, water comes out and the flavor blurs. At the end, sprinkle just a little coarse salt and eat, mopping up the sauce with bread.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Onions and finishing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & where to buy
Thick long onions 8, about 1.75 lb (800 g) With a long white part. About 6 if using very thick leeks
Olive oil 1 tbsp Used thinly only when cooking on a griddle. Not needed under a broiler
Coarse salt 1/2 tsp For finishing. Adjust to the saltiness of the sauce
Country bread or baguette 4 slices Toast and use to mop up the sauce. Bread with a crust suits it better than sandwich bread
Lemon 1/2 Cut into wedges. For adjusting if the sauce is heavy
2 / 2

Salvitxada-style sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & where to buy
Ripe tomatoes 2, about 12.5 oz (360 g) Canned diced tomato tends to turn watery. If using, up to 5.5 oz (150 g)
Garlic 2 cloves Roasted in the skin, then use only the inside
Roasted almonds 1.75 oz (50 g) Unsalted. If you have no hazelnuts, use 2.75 oz (80 g) of almonds in total
Roasted hazelnuts 1 oz (30 g) Unsalted. If you can't find them, substitute almonds
Country bread or baguette 1.5 oz (40 g) Lightly toasted. Pieces of bread suit it better than breadcrumbs
Dried ñora pepper 1 If unavailable, 1 tsp smoked paprika and 1/2 tsp sweet paprika
Smoked paprika 1 tsp Sweet pimentón is close. If hot, start with 1/2 tsp
Olive oil ¼ cup (80 ml) One that is not too strongly scented
Sherry vinegar 2 tbsp With rice vinegar, use 1 1/2 tbsp and check the acidity
Salt 3/4 tsp Run it with 1/2 tsp at first and adjust at the end
Water 2 to 4 tbsp For adjusting thickness. Too much dilutes the flavor
Parsley 10 g Can be omitted, but it cuts the heaviness of the oil
0 / 0

When you char long onions, the kitchen suddenly smells like winter. The outside turns black, scorched nearly to the point of worry, but slip off the skin and a sweet white core appears. Dip it generously in a sauce of nuts and roasted tomato, and a pile of roasted onions becomes a meal that gathers the whole table.

Calçotada comes from Catalonia in northeastern Spain, especially around Valls in the province of Tarragona. The onions are charred until black, wrapped in paper to finish cooking with residual heat, then peeled and sunk into the sauce. Three things matter most: don't be afraid of the char, rest the onions after cooking, and don't make the sauce too smooth.

Calçotada and calçots in Catalonia

The Catalan calçot is an onion earthed up so that its white part grows long. The Valls calçot is a regional product with set standards for the length and thickness of that white part, and the same variety is hard to find elsewhere. Thick long onions with a long white part are the closest substitute.

Locally, the onions go over strong heat close to a direct flame until the outside is black. They are then wrapped in paper to finish cooking, and the burnt outer skin is peeled off at the table. You dip the white part in a sauce called salvitxada, or salsa de calçots. The traditional gesture is to tip your head back and lower the onion into your mouth.

The sauce is close to romesco. Bread, garlic and vinegar give it its thickness and acidity, and the names salsa de calçots, salvitxada and romesco overlap. This version is a salvitxada-style romesco built from roasted tomato, garlic, almonds, hazelnuts, bread, smoked paprika, vinegar and olive oil.

If Fideuà or Paella Valenciana (in Japanese) are dishes you gather around a pan, calçotada is one where you get your hands a little dirty. Don't expect a tidy plate. The black skins, the orange sauce, the bread crumbs and the conversation are all part of it, and that is much closer to the local atmosphere.

Ingredients (serves 4)

Choose long onions with a long, thick white part. With thin scallions or green onions, almost nothing edible is left once the black outer skin is peeled. Thick leek-like onions can be used, but if very thick they cook through slowly, so do not split them lengthwise and give them a little longer.

Ingredients for calçotada: long onions, tomatoes, garlic, nuts, bread, smoked paprika and olive oil laid out
Have thick long onions, roasted tomato, nuts, bread, vinegar and oil ready first
Allergies and food safety

This recipe uses wheat, almonds and hazelnuts. If you have a nut allergy, do not make it. Do not eat the burnt outer skin; eat the inside once peeled. When wrapping the cooked onions in paper, use clean parchment paper or plain food-safe paper.

Choosing onions, paprika and equipment for calçotada

A local charcoal fire is hard to bring indoors, so at home use thick leeks or large scallion-type long onions. You can cook them under a broiler, in the oven or on a griddle. Rather than hunting for the onions themselves, choose thick ones from nearby and put your effort into three things: smoked paprika, a small food processor and a griddle or plancha.

Smoked paprika gives the sauce its local character, adding a smoky, red aroma to the roasted tomato and nuts. If you can't get ñora peppers, use 1 tsp smoked paprika and 1/2 tsp sweet paprika. Think of ñora as a source of red aroma and round sweetness rather than heat, so stick to the paprika instead of reaching for chili flakes; a lot of hot pepper changes the direction of the dish.

The sauce can be made in a mortar, but a small food processor makes it easier to combine nuts, bread and roasted tomato at once. If your broiler is small, cook in batches on a griddle and rotate the onions. You won't get the aroma of an open flame, but you can still blacken the skin and steam the inside.

What to buy Priority Reason Substitute
Smoked paprika High Makes up for the red aroma when you have no ñora pepper Sweet paprika alone gives no smoky aroma
Small food processor Medium Makes it easy to turn nuts and bread into a coarse sauce Crush carefully in a mortar
Griddle or plancha Medium Can cook many onions at once over strong heat Broiler, oven, skillet

How to make it: black outside, sweet inside

Cook the onions slowly over low heat and both the outside and inside turn watery. Char the outer skin first over strong heat, then wrap in paper and foil to finish cooking with residual heat. The outside peels easily, and the inside turns creamy.

Getting the char and the sauce right

The char for calçotada is considerably blacker than for ordinary roasted onions. Unless the outer skin looks "burnt" by home-cooking standards, the core stays hard when peeled. Only the outer skin should blacken, though; cook so long that the white core dries out, and fiber stands out more than sweetness.

The commonest mistake with the sauce is making it too smooth. With no grain at all, it is closer to a red mayonnaise than a vegetable dip. Stop while fine grains of bread and nuts remain, so the sauce clings to each onion.

State Guide How to fix it
Outer skin is only brown Heat is low, cooking time short Raise to high heat and cook 2 more minutes per side
Core is hard Not enough residual heat for the thickness Rest 5 more minutes, still wrapped
Core is watery Surface water remained, or cooked long over low heat Next time wipe before cooking and apply strong heat from the start
Sauce is heavy Too much oil, weak vinegar Add 1 tsp vinegar and 1 tsp lemon juice
Sauce is gritty Nuts too coarse, bread too dry Add 1 tbsp water and blend for only 10 seconds

Serving and storing calçotada

Calçotada on the table with sauce, bread, salad and grilled vegetables
Don't tidy calçotada too much on the plate; peeling it at the table is the fun

At the table

Dipping each onion, lifting it up and lowering it into your mouth looks a little exaggerated at home, but that's exactly why you cook the onions whole. Peeling one, dipping it and chasing it with bread sets a different pace from a table of ordinary side dishes.

In a local calçotada, the onions are followed by meat, sausage, blood sausage, artichokes and so on, all grilled over charcoal. At home, the onions can stay the star with toasted bread, a leafy salad, olives and Tortilla Española. A warm Cocido Madrileño (in Japanese) is a bit heavy alongside, and a cold Gazpacho is better saved for another day. On a hot day, start with Esqueixada (in Japanese), a no-fire Catalan dish whose salt cod and tomato bring a completely different coolness.

A light red, a rosé or a dry sparkling wine suits it. Because the sauce contains nuts and oil, something with acidity is easier to drink than a heavy red. Without alcohol, sparkling water with a squeeze of lemon cuts the lingering oil just as well.

Storage and leftovers

Peeled roasted onions and the sauce stored in separate containers
When storing, keep the peeled onions and the sauce separate

Calçotada is best freshly cooked. For leftovers, remove the burnt outer skin and put only the white core in an airtight container, with the sauce in a separate one. Refrigerate both and finish within about 2 days; stored together, the onions release water by the next day and thin the sauce.

To reheat, use a toaster oven at 350°F (180°C) for 3 to 4 minutes, or roll the onions in a skillet over medium-low heat for about 2 minutes. A microwave alone draws water out of them, so warm at 600 W for 20 seconds and then dry the surface in the toaster oven. The sauce is fine cold, or after 10 minutes at room temperature.

Leftover sauce goes well with roasted chicken, white fish, potatoes and hard-boiled eggs. Stirred into a bean stew like Fabada Asturiana, the nut aroma comes on too strong, so serve it on the side. Spread thinly on bread and toasted, it makes a light lunch the next day.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it with very thick leeks?

Yes. Give them a little longer than long onions: under a broiler, about 8 to 10 minutes on one side and 8 minutes after turning. If the outside is black but the center is still hard, extend the wrapped resting time to 15 minutes.

May I cut the long onions short?

If they don't fit in your broiler, you can cut them in half, though it takes away some of the fun of peeling at the table. Leave them at 6 inches (15 cm) or more rather than 2 inches (5 cm) pieces to keep the calçotada character.

Is it OK to wrap them in newspaper?

Newspaper is used locally, but at home it's easier to wrap the onions in clean parchment paper with aluminum foil on the outside. Make sure no printed side touches the food directly.

Can I make the sauce the day before?

Yes. Refrigerate it in an airtight container and leave it at room temperature for 10 minutes before serving. If the oil has separated, mix it well, and if it feels heavy, add 1 tsp vinegar or 1 tsp lemon juice. The onions, though, keep more aroma when cooked on the day.

Sources