Rogan josh of bone-in mutton simmered in a deep red sauce, served with white rice
Prep8 hr 30 min
Cook2 hr
Serves4 servings
CuisineIndian (Kashmiri)

Rogan Josh Recipe: Kashmir's Red Mutton Curry

A recipe for rogan josh, the red meat stew of Kashmir in northern India, made the Kashmiri Pandit way with no onion or garlic. How to use yogurt, fennel, ginger powder, and asafetida, how to keep the yogurt from splitting, and the origin of the name and the two styles.

Total: 10 hr 30 minLevel: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 6

Marinate the mutton in lemon juice and salt

Rubbing lemon juice and salt into bone-in mutton in a bowl
Rub in lemon juice and salt, and refrigerate for 7 to 8 hours

Cut 1.75 lb (750 g) bone-in mutton into 5 to 6 cm pieces if the pieces are large. Put it in a bowl, add 3 tbsp lemon juice and 1 tsp salt, and rub in for about 1 minute until the salt is no longer gritty and the lemon juice has reached every surface of the meat. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 7 to 8 hours or overnight. Taking time to let the seasoning soak in is the first preparation for this dish. The next day, take it out of the refrigerator 30 minutes before you start cooking.

STEP 22 / 6

Dissolve the spices in the yogurt

Red spice mixture of yogurt with Kashmiri chili powder and fennel
Mix until the ground spices dissolve with no lumps and turn an even red

Put 7 oz (200 g) plain yogurt in a bowl and whisk for about 1 minute until smooth. Add 3 tbsp fennel seed powder, 1 1/2 tbsp ginger powder, 2 tbsp Kashmiri chili powder, and 1 1/2 tsp garam masala, and mix well until there are no lumps. It is ready when the mixture is an even deep red and falls in thick ribbons when scooped.

STEP 33 / 6

Sear the mutton

Searing bone-in mutton in batches in a heavy pot
Don't stack the meat; brown 4 to 5 minutes per side

Heat 3 tbsp mustard oil and 1 tbsp ghee in a heavy pot over medium heat. Lightly wipe the moisture off the mutton, add it to the pot in several batches without overlapping, and brown 4 to 5 minutes per side until well colored, then remove. If you add too much at once, the temperature drops and the meat releases water instead of browning.

STEP 44 / 6

Fry the whole spices and hing, then add the yogurt

Adding the red yogurt and spice mixture to the pot after frying the whole spices
Keep stirring over low heat for about 5 minutes, until the red oil separates and floats

To the oil left in the same pot add the bay leaf, green cardamom, black cardamom, cloves, and cinnamon stick, and fry over medium heat for about 30 seconds. When the spices swell and smell fragrant, add 1 tsp asafetida and stir a few seconds. Immediately reduce to low heat, add the yogurt and spice mixture, and cook it down for about 5 minutes stirring constantly with a wooden spoon. When the oil has turned red and separates and floats at the edges, the spices are cooked.

STEP 55 / 6

Return the mutton and let it meld over low heat

Returning the mutton to the pot, covering it, and letting the red sauce meld over low heat
Coat the meat with sauce, cover, and cook over low heat for about 10 minutes

Return the browned mutton to the pot, add 1/2 tsp salt, and coat the meat all over with the sauce. Cover and cook over low heat for about 10 minutes, stirring occasionally. By then the yogurt sauce should be clinging firmly to the surface of the meat and a little of it sticking to the bottom of the pot. If it looks about to scorch, add about 2 tbsp boiling water and scrape up the bottom.

STEP 66 / 6

Add boiling water and simmer for 1 1/2 hours

Rogan josh simmered with boiling water into a lightly thickened red sauce
Simmer until the meat is tender enough to come off the bone and the sauce thickens lightly

Pour in 3 cups (720 ml) boiling water and mix. When it boils, reduce to medium heat, set the lid on slightly ajar, and simmer about 1 1/2 hours. If the liquid reduces and the meat shows above the surface, top it up with boiling water each time. Cold water would tighten the meat and make it tough, so always add boiling water. It is done when the meat is tender enough to come easily off the bone and the sauce is moderately thick, semi-rich. Taste at the end and adjust with salt.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Seasoning the meat

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bone-in mutton 1.75 lb (750 g) A cut with some fat. Bone-in lamb can substitute
Lemon juice 3 tbsp Squeezed from fresh lemons
Salt (for seasoning) 1 tsp —
2 / 3

Yogurt and spice mixture

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Plain yogurt 7 oz (200 g) Unsweetened
Fennel seed powder 3 tbsp You can also toast the seeds and grind them
Ginger powder 1 1/2 tbsp Powdered dried ginger. Fresh ginger is not a substitute
Kashmiri chili powder 2 tbsp Paprika mixed with a little chili powder can substitute
Garam masala 1 1/2 tsp —
3 / 3

Cooking oil and whole spices

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Mustard oil 3 tbsp Labeled for culinary use. Vegetable oil can substitute
Ghee 1 tbsp Melted unsalted butter also works
Bay leaf 1 —
Green cardamom 2 pods Lightly slit the pods
Black cardamom 1 pod Omit if you don't have it
Cloves 2–3 —
Cinnamon stick 1 inch (2.5 cm) —
Asafetida (hing) 1 tsp —
Boiling water 3 cups (720 ml) For simmering. Prepare extra for topping up separately
Salt 1/2 tsp or more Adjust to taste
0 / 0

The oil in the pot has turned deep red, but there's none of the sharp heat you might expect. What comes through is the sweet scent of fennel and the gentle warmth of dried ginger. Rogan josh is the classic meat dish of Kashmir, a valley in the Himalayas, and the first thing that surprises you is how mild it tastes for how vivid it looks. Bone-in mutton simmers slowly with yogurt and spices until the meat falls off the bone.

Rogan josh in Kashmir

Stirring a pot of red sauce in a Kashmiri home kitchen

The red color

The red comes from Kashmiri chilies, which have a very vivid color and only modest heat. They give the dish its red but not fiery character. Cooks traditionally also added the root or flower of a plant called ratanjot to dye it an even deeper red.

Origins

The dish has Persian roots. It started out as a mildly spiced dish of meat browned in butter. The Mughal Empire brought it to northern India in the 16th century, and in Kashmir it became a local dish. The chilies came later in a sense: they're an American crop that reached India in the early 1500s, when the Portuguese arrived in Goa.

Did you know?

There are several theories about the meaning of the name. One reads the Persian "rogan" (oil, ghee) and "josh" (stewing) as "something stewed in oil." Another holds that "rogan" means "red" in a Kashmiri word and that the dish was named for the color of the sauce. The true origin of the name is still unclear.

Pandit and Muslim styles

Hindus and Muslims in Kashmir make rogan josh differently. The Kashmiri Pandits, the Hindu Brahmins of Kashmir, traditionally cook it without onion or garlic. They build the flavor from the tang and richness of yogurt, from fennel, and from the strong aroma of asafetida (hing). Muslim homes use onions, garlic and local shallots called praan, and rogan josh is one of the dishes in the wazwan, the many-course feast served at celebrations. The recipe below is the Pandit style, with no onion or garlic.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Rogan josh ingredients: bone-in mutton, yogurt, fennel powder, ginger powder, and whole spices

Tip

The amounts of fennel and ginger powder are large, but these two are the center of the Pandit-style flavor. Cut them back and it is just a red yogurt stew. Dissolve all the ground spices in the yogurt first so they don't scorch.

Caution

This dish contains dairy (yogurt, ghee). Some commercial asafetida is mixed with wheat flour to prevent caking. If you have a wheat allergy, always check the ingredient label.

Choosing ingredients for rogan josh

Bone-in lamb, plain yogurt, Kashmiri chili powder, and spices

The traditional meat is mutton (meat from adult sheep) or goat, but plenty of households use lamb. Bone-in lamb (shoulder or chops) or frozen mutton is usually the easiest to find. The bones release flavor as the meat simmers and give the sauce depth, and it helps to choose a cut with some fat.

Kashmiri chili powder is the key to both the color and the flavor. You can find it at Indian grocery stores or online. Ordinary chili powder or chili flakes would make the dish much hotter. If that's all you have, use paprika as the base and mix in just a little chili powder to get close to Kashmiri chili's color and heat.

Tip

Asafetida (hing) gives off a strong sulfur-like smell as soon as you open the bag. The smell can startle you, but when heated in oil it turns into a savory aroma resembling onion and garlic. Because the smell transfers to other foods, store it in a jar with a tight lid.

Mustard oil has a pungent mustard aroma and is widely used in northern India and Kashmir. Indian grocery stores and online shops carry it; buy one labeled for culinary use. Vegetable oil works too. The aroma is milder, but with the ghee the dish still comes out well.


How to make rogan josh

Allow 7 to 8 hours for seasoning the meat, about 30 minutes for preparation, and about 2 hours of cooking including the simmer. If you marinate the meat the night before, it comes together in about 2 1/2 hours the next day.

Caution

Oil spatters easily when mustard oil is heated or when yogurt is added to hot oil. Pour the yogurt mixture in gently from the edge of the pot, and keep your face away from it.

Tip

Yogurt tends to split into curds if added over high heat. If it splits, the taste is not greatly affected, but if you want a smooth sauce, always lower the heat before adding the yogurt mixture. Once the heat is down, keep stirring with the wooden spoon.

Serving rogan josh and variations

A plate of bone-in mutton rogan josh served next to white rice
Plate the meat on the bone and ladle the red sauce over it

Plate the meat on the bone and ladle plenty of sauce over it. The red oil floating on top is a big part of the appeal. The classic partner is white rice, and mixing the sauce into the rice brings out the fennel and ginger. Use basmati if you want it closer to a Kashmiri table.

Naan and chapati are good with it too. Whatever you serve, scoop up every bit of sauce, since that's where the tang of the yogurt and the spices are. If you'd like to try another Indian meat curry, Dhansak (in Japanese) is a good comparison. It's the lentil-and-meat stew of the Parsis, and it uses entirely different spices and gets its sourness a different way.

The Muslim style with onions and the yogurt-based Pandit style of rogan josh side by side

For the Muslim style, fry the whole spices in step 4 as usual. Then add sliced onion or shallot and fry until golden brown, stir in grated garlic, and continue with the yogurt mixture. The onion's sweetness makes it rounder and friendlier, closer to a Japanese-style curry.

Restaurants outside India often add tomato. It's an easy way to get sourness and red color, but it isn't part of the traditional Kashmiri method. You can also make rogan josh made with beef, and brisket is a good cut for it. Beef cuts soften at different rates, so press the meat with chopsticks at the end of the simmer to check that it's tender.

FAQ

Can I eat it if I don't like spicy food?

Yes. It's much milder than it looks. If you're still worried, cut the Kashmiri chili powder to 1 tbsp and add 1 tbsp paprika. You keep the color and lose some of the heat.

What if I don't have time to marinate the meat?

Give it at least 1 hour in the lemon juice and salt. If the marinade time is short, simmer longer in step 6 until the meat is tender enough to come off the bone.

What if I don't have asafetida?

You can leave it out. In the Pandit style, though, asafetida stands in for the savory note of onion and garlic, so the dish tastes a little flatter without it. Adjust the seasoning at the end with salt and garam masala.

Rogan josh being cooled before it goes into a storage container and the refrigerator

Can I make it ahead?

Yes. Like most stews, it tastes better the next day. Once it has cooled, refrigerate it promptly, and when reheating, bring the whole pot to a full boil. Lift off the fat that sets on the surface before you reheat for a cleaner sauce.

Sources