Sri Lankan hot butter cuttlefish coated in spicy butter sauce and sliced green onions
Serves4 servings (or 2 generous servings)
CuisineSri Lankan

Hot Butter Cuttlefish: Sri Lankan Crisp-Fried Cuttlefish in Spicy Garlic Butter

How to make Sri Lankan hot butter cuttlefish: scored cuttlefish strips in a light egg and cornstarch-flour coating, fried in 180°C oil and tossed in a hot sauce of butter, garlic, chili paste and banana peppers. Covers cleaning and scoring, frying-time ranges by thickness, sauce timing, substitutions, allergens, safe handling and the dish's place at the Sri Lankan table.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 12

Open, rinse and score the cuttlefish

Scoring the cuttlefish with shallow diamond cuts that do not go through
Shallow cuts only

Cut each cleaned cuttlefish tube lengthwise so it opens flat, then rinse the opened pieces under running water. If there is a thin membrane on the inside, scrape it off gently with the back of a knife. Make shallow parallel diagonal cuts across the surface, then turn the piece and cut across them to form diamonds. Do not cut all the way through; the scoring helps the seasoning go in, helps the coating cling and helps the cuttlefish cook.

STEP 22 / 12

Cut into strips and season

Resting the seasoned cuttlefish in the refrigerator
A covered bowl goes into the fridge while you prep

Cut the scored cuttlefish into strips about 2 inches wide. After handling the raw cuttlefish, wash your hands, knife, board and work surface before touching other food. Mix the strips with 1/2 tsp salt and 1/2 tsp black pepper, then cover the bowl and let it rest in the refrigerator for at least 15 minutes and up to 1 hour. The strips should be evenly speckled with pepper and chilled through.

STEP 33 / 12

Prepare the aromatics and sauce ingredients

Cut aromatics and measured sauce ingredients set out in separate bowls
Everything ready before the stir-fry

While the cuttlefish rests, finely mince 6–8 cloves of garlic and cut 1/2 large onion into large dice. Cut the 4 dried red chilies into pieces (for less heat, shake out the seeds), slice the banana peppers until you have 2 US cups, and slice 3–4 green onions, white and green parts. Measure the chili paste, oyster sauce, ketchup, butter, oil and sugar, and set everything out in separate bowls, so all of it is within reach before the stir-fry.

STEP 44 / 12

Mix the egg and dry coating

Mixing a whole egg into the rested cuttlefish
The egg helps the coating stick

In a separate bowl, mix 1/2 US cup cornstarch and 1/2 US cup all-purpose flour evenly. Crack 1 egg into the rested cuttlefish and mix until every piece is coated. The cuttlefish should look evenly glossy with egg and the dry coating should be a uniform powder.

STEP 55 / 12

Heat the frying oil to 350°F (180°C)

Checking frying oil in a deep pot with the thermometer probe in the oil; the 180°C target is given in the text
Measure the oil before the first batch

Heat enough oil for deep frying in a deep pot. Check with an oil thermometer, probe in the oil, that it has reached 180°C (350°F). This is the temperature of the oil, not of the cuttlefish. Begin coating only once the thermometer reads 180°C.

STEP 66 / 12

Coat and fry in small batches

Frying cuttlefish in uncrowded batches until the coating is golden
Small batches keep the oil hot

Working a few pieces at a time, toss the egg-coated cuttlefish in the dry coating until every piece is covered. Lower the coated pieces into the oil in small batches and move them gently so they do not stick together. Small pieces take about 1 minute, most take 1–2 minutes, and thick pieces take up to 2–3 minutes; frying too long makes cuttlefish tough. Fry until the coating is golden and crisp and the cuttlefish is cooked through, and let the oil return to 350°F (180°C) between batches.

STEP 77 / 12

Drain the fried cuttlefish

Lifting fried cuttlefish with a slotted spoon to drain on paper towels
Drain every batch before the stir-fry

Lift the pieces out with a slotted spoon and drain on paper towels. Fry all the cuttlefish before starting the sauce. The pieces should sit golden and crisp on the towels, ready for the stir-fry.

STEP 88 / 12

Cook the onion and garlic in butter

Adding minced garlic and stir-frying for 30–60 seconds without burning
Garlic after the onion, briefly

Heat a dry stainless-steel or carbon-steel wok or skillet over medium-high to high heat, then add 1.5 oz (45 g) butter and 1 tbsp vegetable oil. If the pan gets too hot, lift it off the heat for a moment. Add the onion and stir-fry for about 1 minute, then add the minced garlic and stir-fry for 30–60 seconds. Do not let the onion or garlic burn; the butter should be melted and fragrant.

STEP 99 / 12

Build the sauce

Stir-frying chili paste, dried chilies, ketchup, sugar and sauce for about 1 minute
A short, thick sauce

Add 2 1/2 tbsp Sri Lankan chili paste, the dried chilies, 1 1/2 tbsp oyster sauce, 2 1/2 tbsp ketchup and 1/2 tsp sugar. Stir for about 1 minute. If it gets dry, add 1–2 tbsp water. Taste, and add up to another 1/2 tsp sugar only if needed. The sauce should be short and thick.

STEP 1010 / 12

Stir-fry the banana peppers

Stir-frying banana peppers for 1–2 minutes until slightly softened
Peppers just beginning to soften

Add the banana peppers and stir-fry for 1–2 minutes, until just slightly softened; about 1 minute keeps more crunch. If the pan is dry, add about 2 tbsp water, but do not leave much liquid in the pan before the cuttlefish goes in.

STEP 1111 / 12

Toss in the cuttlefish and finish

Adding the fried cuttlefish and tossing it right away in the hot spicy butter sauce
A light glaze keeps the coating crisp

Add the fried cuttlefish and toss right away so each piece is hot and lightly coated with sauce, not sitting in it. Move the pan off the heat and taste a little with a clean spoon; add a little salt only if it needs it. With the pan still hot, stir in the green onions. The coating should still be crisp under a light glaze.

STEP 1212 / 12

Serve at once

Transferring hot butter cuttlefish to a plate to serve right away
Straight from the pan to the table

Transfer to a plate and serve immediately. Steamed rice or fried rice and vegetables can go alongside.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Cleaned cuttlefish tubes 500 g The main ingredient; opened, scored and cut into strips
Egg 1 Binds the dry coating to the cuttlefish
Cornstarch 1/2 US cup Dry coating; crispness
All-purpose flour 1/2 US cup Dry coating
Salt 1/2 tsp Seasoning for the cuttlefish
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Seasoning for the cuttlefish
Vegetable oil as needed For deep frying
Garlic 6–8 cloves, finely minced Aroma for the sauce
Onion 1/2 large, in large dice Sweetness and bite
Sri Lankan chili paste 2 1/2 tbsp Heat and savory depth
Dried red chilies 4 Heat; remove the seeds for a milder dish
Oyster sauce 1 1/2 tbsp Savory depth
Tomato ketchup 2 1/2 tbsp Sweet-sour flavor and a little moisture
Banana peppers 2 US cups, sliced Vegetable, gentle heat
Butter 45 g (about 3 tbsp) Butter flavor of the sauce
Vegetable oil 1 tbsp Cooks with the butter so it is less likely to burn
Sugar 1/2–1 tsp Balances the sauce
Green onions (spring onions) 3–4, sliced Final fresh aroma
Salt to taste Final adjustment, only if needed
Water as needed Loosens the sauce if it gets dry
0 / 0

Strips of cuttlefish, scored in a shallow diamond pattern, come out of the oil with a golden, craggy coating. Moments later they hit a pan of foaming butter, garlic, onion, chili paste and softened banana peppers. They get a quick toss and go to the table with a scatter of green onion. Hot butter cuttlefish is all about contrast: the crunch of the coating, the heat of the chilies, and the rich smell of butter and garlic over everything. You want a thin, crisp shell on tender cuttlefish, with a sauce that clings lightly instead of soaking in, so eat it straight from the pan.

Hot Butter Cuttlefish in Sri Lankan Cooking

Hot butter cuttlefish is a Sri Lankan fusion dish shaped by Sri Lankan Chinese and Hakka cooking. It's built in two stages. The seafood is fried in a light coating, then finished in a separate pan with aromatics, chili and butter.

Seafood landed in Negombo goes on to hotels and restaurants. In a Colombo hotel kitchen, the cuttlefish is fried in hot oil and then tossed with the aromatics in another pan. It's a well-loved tavern dish that usually arrives as one plate in a spread. People eat it as a snack or short eat with cold drinks, or as part of a meal with steamed or fried rice and vegetables.

Home cooks have their own formulas. One version uses 9 oz (250 g) of cuttlefish with flour and corn flour, plus spices such as turmeric. For more of the island's cooking, see more Sri Lankan dishes.

Ingredients (4 servings, or 2 generous servings)

Cuttlefish, egg, cornstarch, flour, aromatics and the ingredients for the spicy butter sauce
The coating side and the sauce side, laid out before cooking

The first group coats and fries the cuttlefish; the second group builds the sauce in the pan.

Allergens

This dish contains cuttlefish (a mollusc), egg, wheat and milk (butter). Sri Lankan chili paste may contain shrimp, oyster sauce contains oyster, and soy sauce or some bottled sauces contain soy. Products differ, so check the label of each chili paste, chili crisp, oyster sauce and soy sauce, including any shared-facility or cross-contact statements.

Equipment

  • Cutting board and sharp knife
  • Kitchen scissors (for the dried chilies)
  • Several bowls for seasoning, coating and the prepared aromatics
  • Deep pot for frying
  • Oil thermometer
  • Slotted spoon
  • Paper towels for draining
  • Large stainless-steel or carbon-steel wok or skillet (a nonstick pan is not suited to this high heat)

Choosing Ingredients for Hot Butter Cuttlefish

Cuttlefish. Look for cleaned cuttlefish tubes, fresh or frozen. They save you the cleaning and make it easier to cut even pieces. Squid or calamari can stand in, but they're a different animal with a different texture, so think of that as a squid version of the dish.

Banana peppers. Hungarian peppers work, as do about 1 cup of seeded jalapeños or sweet bell peppers. Bell peppers make the dish sweeter and milder. Jalapeños bring more heat, though removing the seeds tames it.

Sri Lankan chili paste. It can include shrimp, which adds savory depth. If you can't find it, use the solid chili part of a Chinese-style chili crisp or chili oil, without pouring in the extra oil. The flavor and the allergens will both change, so read the label. Oyster sauce is optional, but it's especially useful when you skip the Sri Lankan chili paste.

Butter. Margarine works as an alternative at 1.5 oz (45 g). If you're avoiding dairy, check that the margarine itself is dairy-free.

Starch and flour. Potato starch can replace cornstarch, but it can change how the coating crisps. Swapping in other flours for all-purpose flour will change the texture too.

Finishing seasoning. Finish with salt, as this recipe does, or with a little soy sauce, but pick one. Keep in mind that soy sauce adds soy as an allergen.

Method

How the cooking flows

Preparation takes time; the stir-fry takes only a few minutes. Have every sauce ingredient cut and measured before the oil goes on, and fry all the cuttlefish before you start the sauce.

Fixing Hot Butter Cuttlefish

Problem Likely cause What to do
The coating browns before the cuttlefish is cooked, or the cuttlefish is tough Oil too hot or too cool, pieces of uneven thickness, frying too long Keep the oil at 350°F (180°C), fry in small batches, and lift each piece out once it is golden and cooked through
The coating turns soft Crowded pot, too much liquid in the sauce, waiting before serving Fry in uncrowded batches, keep the sauce thick before the cuttlefish goes in, and serve as soon as it is tossed
The garlic tastes bitter Butter and oil too hot, garlic cooked too long Add the garlic after the onion and move on after 30–60 seconds; lift the pan off the heat if it is too hot
Too spicy Chili seeds, hot peppers Seed or omit the dried chilies, use sweet bell peppers, or use a little less chili paste (the flavor softens too)
Too sharp or too flat Sugar out of balance Start with 1/2 tsp sugar and go up to 1 tsp only if needed
Safe handling and leftovers
  • Keep raw seafood away from other foods. Wash hands, boards, knives and surfaces after handling it.
  • Refrigerate or freeze seafood soon after buying. If you will use it within 2 days, keep it in a refrigerator at 4.4°C (40°F) or below.
  • Cook the cuttlefish until its internal temperature reaches 145°F (about 63°C). Use a thermometer; color, frying time and photos do not show that it is safe. The 180°C in this recipe is the oil temperature, not the temperature inside the cuttlefish.
  • The texture is best right after cooking, so eat it the same day, ideally within 1 hour. For safety, do not leave cooked seafood at room temperature for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour when the temperature is above 32°C. Cool any leftovers, cover them and refrigerate them right away. This dish is not suited to making ahead.

Serving Hot Butter Cuttlefish

Serve it the moment it's tossed, while the coating is still crackling. Enjoy it on its own with cold drinks, or set it out with steamed rice or fried rice and vegetables. The swaps above double as variations: a squid version, a milder one with bell peppers, or a chili crisp version with the oyster sauce kept in.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does the frying time vary?

Thickness matters. Small pieces take about 1 minute, most take 1–2 minutes, and thick pieces can take 2–3 minutes. Go by the signs rather than the clock: oil held at 350°F (180°C), a golden, crisp coating and cuttlefish cooked through. Remember that the oil temperature isn't the temperature inside the food, and that frying too long makes the cuttlefish tough.

Why rest the cuttlefish in the refrigerator?

Seasoned raw cuttlefish should stay cold while it rests. Cover it and keep it in the refrigerator, not on the counter, for at least 15 minutes and up to 1 hour.

Sources