In the pot, small potatoes sit wrapped in a sauce of blazing red, and yet in the mouth it is surprisingly not hot. What stays on the tongue is the soft sourness of yogurt, the sweet scent of fennel and the gentle warmth of dried ginger. There's no onion, no garlic, no tomato. This is Kashmiri dum aloo, a potato dish handed down in the homes of the Hindu Kashmiri Pandits, in the Himalayan valley of Kashmir in India's far north.
Kashmiri Dum Aloo and the Pandit Kitchen

Kashmiri cooking falls into several broad traditions. Wazwan, the Muslim banquet cuisine, and the Dogra cooking of the Jammu region lean on onion, tomato and a wide range of spices. The cooking of the Pandits, the Kashmiri Brahmins, stands apart by using no onion or garlic.
In their place, the Pandit kitchen builds its aroma on turmeric, Kashmiri chili, asafoetida (hing), dried ginger powder and fennel. Add plenty of yogurt and a plate of rice, especially basmati, and you have the basis of the Pandit table.
It is said that the Kashmiri Pandit cooking's avoidance of onion and garlic stems from food rules from the Vedic era. Asafoetida, which they use in their place, has long been a prized spice in India in the kitchens of people who do not eat onion or garlic.
"Dum" refers to cooking slowly in a covered pot, in its own trapped steam, and "aloo" is potato. The small potatoes are fried first, then braised with the sauce under a lid so the flavor soaks all the way in.
The red comes from Kashmiri chili powder, a chili with vivid color and very gentle heat. For an even deeper red, steep ratanjot root in the oil; skip red food dye.
Ingredients (serves 4)

Store-bought asafoetida powder is often mixed with wheat flour to make it easier to handle, so people with a wheat allergy should check the ingredients. Mustard oil is an oil from a seed of the same Brassicaceae family as mustard, and yogurt is a dairy product. Putting boiled potatoes into hot oil makes it spatter, so wipe them dry before adding.
Choosing Ingredients for Dum Aloo

Use small new potatoes that can be eaten in one bite. The dish keeps to the pillars of Pandit aroma, fennel, dried ginger and asafoetida, with no cashew paste or mixed spices to crowd them out.
The three spices worth seeking out are Kashmiri chili powder, fennel powder and asafoetida, all available at Indian groceries or online. Asafoetida is a powdered resin that smells a lot like onion and garlic, and just a pinch gives the whole dish an umami-like depth. Ginger powder (dried ginger) is in the supermarket spice aisle.
Asafoetida is extremely pungent, and opening the bag alone spreads the smell through the kitchen. After using it, close it tightly and store it in an airtight container separate from the other spices. When it goes into hot oil, the harsh smell settles and turns into a gentle aroma.
For the yogurt, choose fresh plain yogurt that isn't very sour. If yours has turned sour, pour off the liquid floating on top first so the sauce won't get too sharp.
How to make Kashmiri dum aloo
Including the time to boil the potatoes, it takes about 1 hour in all. Mixing the yogurt sauce while the potatoes boil speeds things along.
If yogurt is heated quickly over high heat, it splits into curds. The trick is to lower the heat to its lowest, add it little by little, and return the heat after it is all mixed in. Even if it splits a little, keep stirring and cook until the oil seeps out, and the flavor is fine.
Putting boiled potatoes into hot mustard oil makes the oil spatter easily. Wipe the potatoes well with paper towels and add them gently, keeping your face away from the pan.
Serving and Variations

In a Pandit home, dum aloo is eaten with basmati rice. Mix the red sauce into the rice, break up the potatoes as you go, and the aroma of fennel and dried ginger fills your mouth. Because the heat is mild, even people who shy away from spicy food tend to enjoy it. It's also good with chapati or roti.
Set it beside rogan josh (in Japanese), lamb simmered in red, for a table of Kashmir's red dishes. Or compare it with the northern Indian home dish aloo gobi (in Japanese) to see how differently the two use their spices.

When baby potatoes are out of season, peel ordinary potatoes and cut them into 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes. Shorten the boiling to 8–10 minutes and roll them gently while pan-frying so the corners stay intact. A drizzle of about 2 tbsp cream at the end gives a mellow, restaurant-style flavor.
If you like heat, raising the Kashmiri chili powder to 3 tsp makes it only slightly hotter while deepening the color. Two green chilies add real heat. For a dairy-free version, use plant-based yogurt.
FAQ

Can't I make it without asafoetida?
You can, but in a dish with no onion or garlic, asafoetida is the base of the aroma, and the flavor comes out a bit flat without it. Try to get some if you can.
Is it really not hot?
Kashmiri chili powder gives only a mild tingle. The same amount of crushed red pepper or ordinary chili powder would make it fiery, so if you need a substitute, use paprika.
Can I make it ahead?
Let it cool slightly, then refrigerate it in a storage container and finish it within 2 days. Over time the potatoes absorb the sauce and the flavors blend further. To reheat, add a little water and warm slowly over low heat.
The yogurt split.
That happens when the heat is too high or the yogurt goes in all at once. The flavor doesn't change, so keep stirring and cook until the oil seeps out. If the look bothers you, turn off the heat and whisk quickly to bring back some smoothness.













