Deep crimson borscht in a soup bowl with a white swirl of sour cream
Prep30 min
Cook2 hr 10 min
Serves6 servings
CuisineUkrainian

Borscht: Ukrainian Beef and Beet Soup

A borscht recipe for six, a Ukrainian home dish that makes the most of beef and the sweetness of beets. Explains the order in which to add sourness, the heat that keeps the color, substitutes for ingredients you may not find, and storage and reheating, along with the background of the table. Also covers how to use dill and sour cream.

Total: 2 hr 40 minLevel: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 6

Make a stock with the beef

about 15 min until it boils and is skimmed + 75–90 min on low heat.

The step of skimming scum from the beef
Beginning to simmer the beef and skimming the scum from the surface

Cut the beef into 2 inches (5 cm) cubes and put it in a large pot with 2.75 quarts (2.5 L) cold water, over high heat. When it boils, skim the white scum that floats on the surface for 3 to 4 minutes. Add the onion, carrot, bay leaves and black peppercorns, and drop to low heat where small bubbles keep rising. Simmer 75–90 minutes with the lid slightly ajar. When a skewer goes into the meat smoothly and the broth is not too cloudy, move on. If the broth falls below 2 quarts (2 L), add boiling water.

STEP 22 / 6

Take out the meat and cut the vegetables

20 min to cut the vegetables (can be done while the beef simmers).

The step of taking out the meat and chopping vegetables
Shred the beef and cut the beets and vegetables to the same size

Take the meat out of the pot, and once cool enough, shred it into easy-to-eat pieces along the grain. Do not use the onion and carrot from the stock; take them out. Strain the broth through a fine sieve and return 2–2.25 quarts (2.0–2.2 L) to the pot.

Cut the cabbage in 3–4 cm strips and the potatoes in 0.5 inch (1.5 cm) cubes. Keep the potatoes in water. Slice the onion 0.25 inch (5 mm), cut the carrot and celery into 0.125 inch (3 mm) matchsticks, and mince the garlic about 0.125 inch (2 mm). Cut the boiled beets into matchsticks and set aside the liquid from the can or jar.

STEP 33 / 6

Sauté the beets and add the sourness

10 min.

The step of sautéing onion, carrot and beets with tomato paste
Briefly sauté the beets and make a sweet-sour colorful base with vinegar and sugar

Put 2 tbsp oil in a skillet and fry the onion for 5 minutes over medium heat. When it is translucent, add the carrot and celery and fry 3 more minutes. Add the tomato paste and fry 1 minute, and when the oil has turned red, add the beets.

Sauté the beets for only 2–3 minutes, add the vinegar and sugar and mix about 30 seconds. It is enough when the vegetables are wilted, the tomato paste has blended smoothly with the oil, and the surface of the beets has returned to red-violet. Scorching here makes the earthiness stronger, so if the bottom of the pan starts to dry out, add just 1 tbsp of the reserved beet liquid.

STEP 44 / 6

Simmer the potatoes and cabbage

25 min.

The step of simmering potatoes and cabbage in the soup
Simmer the potatoes first, and add the quick-cooking cabbage later

Put the strained beef stock over medium heat and, when it boils, add the potatoes. Simmer 15 minutes at a heat where the surface moves quietly, and when a skewer goes slightly into the center, add the cabbage. Simmer 10 more minutes, until the core of the cabbage is not too crisp and the leaves have not fallen apart. Add 1 tsp salt and season here.

STEP 55 / 6

Return the sautéed beets and the beef

10 min.

The step of adding the sautéed vegetables and shredded meat to the soup
Near the end, bring back the beets, beef and sautéed vegetables to bring together the color and flavor

When the cabbage is tender enough to eat, add the sautéed vegetables from step 3, the shredded beef and the beet liquid. Simmer over low heat for only 8–10 minutes. If big bubbles rise continuously, lower the heat a notch. It has worked when a thin film of red oil floats on the surface, the ingredients are evenly warm, and the beets are soft enough to cut with chopsticks.

Taste, and if the sourness is weak, add vinegar 1 tsp at a time; if the sweetness is short, add sugar a pinch at a time. Do not increase the salt all at once; add a pinch, mix and check.

STEP 66 / 6

Finish with garlic and dill

5 min + 10 min resting.

The step of the final seasoning and dill
Add the dill right before turning off the heat and finish with its aroma intact

Add the garlic, black pepper and finely chopped dill and cook 1 minute over low heat. When the edges of the garlic have softened, the dill floats evenly on the soup surface and the aroma rises, turn off the heat and cover. Rest 10 minutes and the aroma settles into the broth. If you use dried dill, add it here too. Do not simmer it long; finish while the green aroma remains.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Beef stock

Ingredient Amount Role & substitutes
Beef short rib or beef shank 1 lb (500g) About 2 inches (5 cm) cubes. If using bone-in meat, count the edible portion as the same amount
Water 2.75 quarts (2.5L) About 2–2.25 quarts (2.0–2.2 L) should remain after simmering
Onion 1 Peel and halve. For the stock only, not put in at the end
Carrot 1 Halve lengthwise. For the stock
Bay leaf 2 Nothing special
Black peppercorns 8 Nothing special
Salt 1 tsp Seasoning for the stock. Adjust at the end looking at the whole
2 / 3

The borscht itself

Ingredient Amount Role & substitutes
Beets (canned or jarred, boiled in water) 14 oz (400g) net Use the liquid too. If pickled, make the adjustments below
Cabbage 1/4 head (about 10.5 oz (300 g)) Cut in strips 3–4 cm
Potatoes 2 medium (about 10.5 oz (300 g)) 0.5 inch (1.5 cm) cubes. A variety that does not fall apart is easier to handle
Onion 1 Sliced 0.25 inch (5 mm)
Carrot 1 Cut in 0.125 inch (3 mm) matchsticks
Celery 1 stalk Thinly sliced on the diagonal. Can be omitted if you have none
Garlic 3 cloves Minced about 0.125 inch (2 mm)
Tomato paste 2 tbsp 3.5 oz (100 g) canned tomatoes also work, but drive off a little of the water
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp For frying
Sugar 1 tsp Links the sourness and the sweetness of the beets
Vinegar (white distilled, white wine vinegar and the like) 1 tbsp If using pickled beets, leave it out at first and add a little after tasting
Salt 1 1/2–2 tsp Adjust looking at the saltiness of the stock and the beet liquid
Black pepper (ground) 1/2 tsp For finishing
Dill 10 g fresh, or 2 tsp dried Added right before turning off the heat
3 / 3

Finishing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Sour cream 3.5–5.5 oz (100–150g) 3 tbsp unsweetened yogurt plus 1 tbsp heavy cream also works
Dark bread or rye bread 6 slices Any easy-to-find bread can substitute
0 / 0

Lift the lid a little and the earthy scent of beets rises with the steam of the beef, followed by sweet cabbage, sour tomato and the green aroma of dill. Ladle it into a bowl, drop a spoonful of sour cream on top, and a white swirl unfurls across the deep crimson surface. Borscht (борщ) is Ukraine's great beet soup, sweet and sour with the umami of meat. The color and sweetness depend on when the beets go in. Make a beef stock first, simmer the potatoes and cabbage in it, and bring the sautéed beets back near the end. Follow that order and a home pot gets the balance right.

Borscht in Ukrainian homes

Borscht belongs to homes and regions, not to any one restaurant. Every pot differs: the type of meat, how the sourness is added, whether there are beans or mushrooms, even the bread on the side. So instead of looking for the one essential ingredient, look at how the stock, the sourness and the herbs are layered around the sweet, earthy aroma of beets.

In 2022, the "Culture of Ukrainian borscht cooking" was added to the List of Intangible Cultural Heritage in Need of Urgent Safeguarding. The listing covers no single recipe and no claim to the dish. It covers the practice itself: homes, communities and cooks choosing ingredients, gathering around the pot and handing the method down to the next generation, at a time when war is disrupting people's lives. Details are on the inscription page.

Borscht turns up in homes, canteens and restaurants in every region, at everyday meals and at celebrations. Far from Ukraine, it makes more sense to cook your own household's pot than to copy one particular plate. This beef version is also one of them.

A combination of deep crimson borscht, sour cream and dark bread
Part of the enjoyment of borscht at the table is the contrast between red soup and white sour cream

Regional versions of borscht

Regional difference is part of how the dish works. The base is a meat, poultry or mild fish stock with beets or beet kvass, potatoes and cabbage. Cooks then add what grows locally, such as mushrooms, fish or sweet peppers. The sourness varies too: tomato, fermented milk, sour cream, vinegar, lemon and more.

How the flavor is built

This recipe builds its flavor in three layers:

  • Stock: beef short rib or beef shank, simmered over low heat, makes a base that holds the vegetables.
  • Sweetness and color: beets, onion, carrot and tomato paste are sautéed, which adds a toasty note.
  • Sourness and aroma: vinegar goes into the pan with the beets, and dill and sour cream finish the bowl.

Ingredients (serves 6)

If you choose boiled beets, there is less preparation and the way the color comes out is easier to read. If the label says "pickled," sourness and sugar are already in it, so do not put in the full amount of vinegar and sugar from the start. First taste a little of the liquid and adjust only if the sourness is short.

The vivid red-violet cross-section of cut raw beets
The red-violet of raw beets stains hands and cutting boards easily. Decide where you will work before cutting
About allergies

The soup itself uses no wheat, but the bread served alongside may contain wheat or rye. Because it uses sour cream or heavy cream, also check the dairy. Processed beets and seasonings differ in ingredients by product, so check the label if needed.

Choosing beets, herbs and a pot for borscht

Canned, fresh or pickled beets

  • Boiled, canned or jarred: the base for this recipe. Keep the liquid and cut the beets into matchsticks. Use the liquid for the final adjustment of sourness and color.
  • Fresh beets: roast unpeeled at 350°F (180°C) for 40–60 minutes, and let them cool once a skewer goes through. Peel and cut into matchsticks. Size changes the timing, so go by tenderness rather than the clock.
  • Pickled beets: the liquid is already sour and sweet. Hold back the vinegar and sugar, add the beets and their liquid, then adjust a little at a time.

Fresh beets leave red juice on cutting boards and cloth. Lay down a disposable sheet or use a board you don't mind staining, and wear gloves if you have them. If that sounds like a chore, boiled beets are a perfectly smart choice.

White distilled vinegar or rice vinegar works fine. Red wine vinegar gives the sourness a fruity roundness and is worth buying if you'll use it in dressings and braises too. For this one pot, use the vinegar you have.

Dill and other substitutes

Fresh dill does more than anything else to shape the aroma, but you can make the soup without it. Dried dill, 2 tsp added right before you turn off the heat, still lifts the heaviness of meat and beets. Buy it if you'll use it again in fish soup, potato dishes or cucumber salad, and check the label for whether it is freeze-dried, the package size and the ingredients. Otherwise a little parsley scattered at the end fills in the green note, though it lacks dill's sweet, cool aroma.

Celery can be left out. Ordinary bread is fine in place of dark bread.

The pot

An ordinary heavy lidded pot handles the beef simmering. An enameled cast-iron pot holds low heat easily and can go straight to the table. It is heavy and expensive, though, so it is worth buying only if you make soups and braises often and will use a pot of around 8.5 inches (22 cm) regularly. If you already have a heavy pot and just want to try this once, skip it.

Common borscht failures and fixes

Most borscht problems come down to the beets. Their main pigments, betalains, react to pH, heat and oxygen. Betanin is fairly stable in mild acidity (around pH 4–5), but it breaks down and browns the longer it is heated. Vinegar alone won't save the color. Sauté the beets briefly with the acid, and return them to the soup at the end. For the science, see this review.

Tip

Briefly sauté the beets with vinegar, then return them to the soup at the end. Boiling hard for a long time after the beets go in dulls the red color.

Borscht with a faded color next to borscht finished in deep crimson
The timing and heat at which the beets go in change the impression of the red

The color is brownish

The beets went in too early, or the soup boiled hard near the end. Next time, sauté the beets and bring them back for the last 8–10 minutes. To rescue this pot, briefly warm a small amount of beets with 1 tsp vinegar and stir it in after turning off the heat. That adds sourness, so recheck the salt and sugar, a very little at a time.

The flavor is thin

Usually more than 2 quarts (2 L) of stock is left, or the salt is short. Before you add more seasoning, take off the lid and let water cook off over low heat for 5–10 minutes, then add salt a pinch at a time. If the meat flavor is weak, cut the beef in larger pieces next time and keep the heat low after skimming.

Too sour

This happens when all the liquid from pickled beets goes in. Add hot stock or water a little at a time, plus a pinch of sugar to round it out. Sour cream in the bowl adds even more sourness, so start with a little.

An earthy smell remains

The beets were cut too large, the sautéing was too short, or the canned liquid has a strong smell. With boiled beets, keep only 1–2 tbsp of the liquid, cut them into matchsticks and coat them well with the onion and tomato paste. Fresh beets do best roasted, which brings out their sweetness.

The cabbage is too soft

It simmered too long. Potatoes go in first; cabbage goes in later so it keeps some bite. If you'll reheat part of the pot the next day, slightly firm cabbage on the first day is just right.

Serving, variations and storing borscht

Serving

Finished deep crimson borscht filling a large pot
Borscht for six. Put the sour cream in the bowl right before eating

Pour the hot borscht into deep bowls and top each with 1–2 tbsp sour cream. Don't stir it in right away. Eat it while the red and white are still marbled and the sourness shifts from bite to bite. If you're using unsweetened yogurt and heavy cream instead, add that in the bowl too, never in the pot.

A single serving of borscht with sour cream and dill
Do not mix the sour cream and dill into the pot; adjust the amount in the bowl

Borscht comes in a deep plate with bread, bread rubbed with garlic, and herbs such as dill and parsley. Some households set out garlic, onion and salo (salt-cured pork fat) as well. Sour rye or ordinary bread works if you have no dark bread, and dipping it in the soup soaks up the sweetness of the beets.

Borscht with dark bread and dill
Serve with dark bread and dill, and combine the sour cream in the bowl

For another Eastern European table where meat and sourness meet, try Belarusian machanka. Bulgaria's mish-mash is a lighter home dish of eggs and vegetables, very different from a red braise. For a cold soup, compare Russia's okroshka.

Variations

Keep each ingredient's role when you swap, and the flavor holds together.

  • The beef version is a rich soup built on the umami of meat. With cabbage and potatoes, as here, it makes a full meal.
  • A meatless version gets its body from mushrooms and white beans. If you switch to a stock of kombu and dried shiitake, treat it as your own plant-based take rather than a Ukrainian home dish.
  • Green borscht is a different soup, made with sorrel, leafy greens and eggs. Made with spinach and lemon, it's best enjoyed as a "green sour soup."
Green borscht with leafy greens and egg
Green borscht with leafy greens, spreading in a different direction from red borscht

A soup made red with tomato alone is not the same as borscht. If you can't find beets, make a good tomato soup, and save borscht for the day you do.

Storing and reheating

Don't leave leftovers in the pot at room temperature. Divide them into shallow containers and cool them quickly. Refrigerate for 3–4 days, or freeze for 3–4 months. Reheat to 74°C (165°F), and if you're unsure how the soup was stored, don't eat it, even within those days. See the leftovers safety guide.

To keep the color, warm one serving at a time in a separate pot instead of reboiling the whole batch. For safety heat it thoroughly to the center, and put the sour cream and fresh dill in the bowl. Potatoes turn crumbly when frozen, so use fewer in the portion you'll freeze, or boil them separately on the day you eat it and add them then.

Borscht divided into storage containers
Divide it into shallow containers by portion and refrigerate or freeze

FAQ

Can I simmer the beef in a pressure cooker?

Yes, for the stock step. Follow the manual, including the natural pressure release, and cook until the meat shreds. Once the beets are in, switch to an ordinary pot over low heat and don't pressurize.

I have no sour cream.

Mix 3 tbsp unsweetened yogurt with 1 tbsp heavy cream and spoon it into the bowl. Yogurt alone works too, but it's sharper, so start with 1 tsp. Always add it after serving, because it separates in a pot that is still cooking.

Sources

The quantities and steps are the editorial team's proposal, assembling the axes of flavor above for home cooks. The cultural background, handling of the pigment and storage safety information refer to the following.