Spinach and walnut pkhali topped with pomegranate seeds
Prep3 hr 25 min
Cook5 min
Serves4 servings
CuisineGeorgian

Spinach Pkhali: A Georgian Cold Appetizer of Spinach and Walnuts

Pkhali is a Georgian appetizer of chopped vegetables blended with walnuts. A four-serving spinach recipe with draining, grinding the walnuts, chilling time and shaping cues, plus spring wild-greens pkhali from Imereti, regional differences, sourcing the spices, fixing a mixture that will not hold together, storage and allergy notes.

Total: 3 hr 30 minLevel: Beginner

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 5

Wash the leaves and herbs

Washed, drained spinach and chopped herbs
Remove the soil at the base and blot the moisture from the herbs too

Open out the base of each spinach plant and wash under running water to remove soil, then cut off the hard stems. Do not leave the leaves soaking in water for long. Wash the cilantro and parsley, drain, and blot off excess water with paper. Mince the onion to 2–3 mm and press the garlic until it is crushed flat. Put 2 quarts (2 L) water and about 6 g salt for the cooking water into a large pot and bring it to a boil over heat. Washing and chopping take about 15 minutes. Use a clean cutting board and utensils for the leaves after they have been cooked.

STEP 22 / 5

Boil the spinach

Spinach softening in boiling water
About 5 minutes after the water returns to a boil softens the leaves

Put the spinach in the boiling water and push the leaves down as they wilt. When it returns to a boil, lower to medium heat and cook for about 5 minutes. It is ready to lift out when the leaves are soft and the stems crush easily when pressed with a finger or spoon. If hard stems remain, cook a little longer. Do not lift it out early to keep the bright color of fresh leaves; check that it has become soft enough to mix in finely.

STEP 33 / 5

Cool and squeeze out the water

Squeezed spinach and chopped leaves
Squeeze a handful at a time until water no longer keeps dripping

Put the leaves in a colander and spread them out to cool for about 30 minutes, until they can be touched by hand. With clean hands, squeeze a small amount at a time so that it no longer drips when pressed. Move the squeezed leaves to the cutting board and chop to about 0.125 inch (3 mm). Any long leaves or stems left behind are hard to cut, and shaping goes poorly. Do not leave it out at room temperature; on a hot day, spread it in a shallow container and cool it in the refrigerator.

STEP 44 / 5

Make the walnut base

Seasoned base of ground walnuts and chopped herbs
Grind the nuts fine and do not run the machine too long

Put the walnuts and garlic in a food processor and pulse in short bursts until they look like fine, moist breadcrumbs. Allow about 10 minutes. Do not run it long enough to turn it into a fully liquid nut butter. The target is a fine grain, with no large pieces standing out. Add the chopped onion, herbs, blue fenugreek, edible marigold, chili powder, the optional 1/2 tsp ground coriander and 3 tbsp (42 ml) white wine vinegar, and mix until everything is evenly distributed. Add part of the 1 g of salt for mixing, saving the rest for adjusting the seasoning after the spinach is combined. If raw onion tastes too sharp, rinse the minced onion briefly in water and drain it well.

STEP 55 / 5

Mix, chill and roll into small balls

Thick paste of mixed spinach and walnuts
Check for a thickness that keeps the mark of the spoon, then refrigerate

Combine the chopped spinach with the seasoned base and mix evenly with clean hands or a spoon. Mix for 10 minutes. Taste and adjust with the reserved salt and the heat. It is the right thickness if a spoonful holds a mound and, set on a plate, no water spreads out. Put it in a shallow clean container, cover and chill in the refrigerator for 2 hours. Do not rest it for 2 hours at room temperature. Once chilled, divide it with clean, slightly dampened hands into about 8 pieces, roll them and flatten them slightly. Serve two pieces per person as an appetizer, garnished with 20 g pomegranate and the reserved cilantro.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Vegetables and nuts

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Spinach 1.25 lb (600 g) Raw weight. Rinse off soil at the base
Walnuts 4 oz (120 g) Shelled, unsalted. Do not use ones coated with sugar or salt
Onion 4/5 Very finely minced. Adjust to taste for differences in sharpness by size
Garlic 2 cloves Peeled and crushed
Cilantro 20 g Leaves and tender stems. Set a little aside for the finish
Parsley 20 g Hard stems removed, minced
Pomegranate seeds 20 g For finishing. Leave out if you cannot get them
2 / 2

Spices and seasonings

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Blue fenugreek (powder) 2/5 tsp Utskho suneli. Do not treat it as the same ingredient as ordinary fenugreek. If you do not have it, leave it out and accept the difference in aroma
Edible marigold (powder) 2/5 tsp Dried flower used in Georgian cooking. Can be omitted if you do not have it
Ground coriander 1/2 tsp Optional. Ground seeds. Some local recipes add a little in addition to fresh cilantro
Chili powder 1.2 tsp Start with a small amount if you do not like heat. Equivalent to 0.4 tbsp
White wine vinegar 3 tbsp (42 ml) A little over 2 tbsp plus 2 tsp. Rice vinegar works but the aroma changes
Salt 7 g Split into about 6 g for the cooking water and about 1 g for mixing; do not add all of the latter at once
Water 2 quarts (2 L) A guide for the cooking water. Enough for the leaves to sink in a large pot
0 / 0

Small, dark green balls of spinach and walnut sit on a serving plate, scattered with red pomegranate seeds, and beside them lies baked bread, torn into pieces for scooping up a little at a time. This quiet dish of vegetables and walnuts is pkhali (ფხალი), a cold appetizer from the Georgian table. Chopped vegetables are combined with nuts, herbs, garlic and vinegar. It looks plain, but once it is in your mouth the richness of walnut, the sourness and the green scent of herbs arrive one after another.

This version uses spinach, and the cooking is mostly just boiling the leaves. Then you squeeze them, chop them, mix them with the nut mixture and chill, and the fat and fine grains of walnut bind everything together. Whether it holds its shape for rolling comes down to one thing: draining decides how well it holds together.

Pkhali in Georgia: one method, many vegetables

Pkhali on a table with bread
Pkhali as a small appetizer served with bread

Pkhali can be made with leeks, cabbage, eggplant and other vegetables as well as spinach. The name refers to a method of seasoning vegetables and nuts and combining them, so think of it as a dish where you swap the vegetable.

There is also a kind made from spring wild greens, called field pkhali. It is made across Georgia and is especially associated with the Imereti region, where the tradition of making field pkhali in Upper Imereti has been given the status of intangible cultural heritage. When it began and who first made it are not known.

The wild-greens version has regional styles of its own. In Guria, cooks use hazelnuts, herbs and vinegar; in Kartli, onion sautéed in oil and young garlic. In Samegrelo, some versions add sour tkemali and red chili.

Good to know

The wild-greens version is not squeezed too hard, and its consistency is adjusted with the cooking liquid. A rolled spinach version like this one starts from squeezing out the water well, so the same name can call for different draining depending on the shape you want. If you plan to roll it, drain well.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Spinach, walnuts, herbs and seasonings
Gather herbs and vinegar around the spinach and walnuts

Before shopping, check the quantities. 1.25 lb (600 g) of raw spinach and 4 oz (120 g) of walnuts make an appetizer for 4. That is the raw weight, not the weight after boiling. Plan for about 1 hour 25 minutes of prep, 5 minutes of boiling and 2 hours in the refrigerator, about 3 hours 30 minutes in total.

Tip

The cilantro you pick up in the herb section is the one whose fresh leaves and tender stems you use. It is a different ingredient from ground, dried coriander seed, so keep the herb and the seed powder apart. For blue fenugreek, check that the label says utskho suneli or blue fenugreek. Do not swap in ordinary fenugreek in the same amount. Without edible marigold, leave it out; the aroma will differ from the local blend.

Method

The order is simple. Boil the leaves and cool them, then squeeze before chopping. After mixing with the seasoned nut base, there is no more cooking. Allow 2 hours in the refrigerator. Just before eating, garnish with pomegranate and the cilantro you set aside.

Tip

In a kitchen without a food processor, chop the walnuts again and again with a knife. Chop a small amount at a time so that no large pieces remain. Large nut pieces do not blend with the leaves, and the mixture crumbles easily. You do not need a perfectly smooth paste; just make sure no big fragments are left in the mouth. Chopping by hand takes longer than using a machine.

When spinach pkhali will not hold together

Water seeping out on the plate usually means the leaves or herbs were not drained enough. If the leaves have not been mixed yet, squeeze them again. Once everything is mixed, give it the 2 hours in the refrigerator before judging, and resist fixing separated water with extra oil or vinegar. Check whether water seeps on the plate after chilling.

Texture problems usually come from the grain size. Long leaves make the surface of the balls crack, so chop finer before mixing; large walnut pieces make it fall apart, so grind them more finely next time. If it simply dries out and cracks even after chilling, add clean drinking water 1 tsp at a time and mix.

If it still will not roll, spread it in a shallow dish and serve it that way. That only changes the texture, though. It will not rescue a dish that has spoiled.

Tip

Chili heat varies by product, so start small; it is hard to reduce once mixed. Add vinegar little by little too, rather than adding sugar or oil afterward to cancel the sourness. Raw onion sharpness is a different thing from chili heat, so adjust the onion when you chop it.

Serving and storing pkhali

Serve the chilled pkhali in small portions, topped with red pomegranate seeds and herbs, with bread alongside. Taken a little at a time, each bite brings out a different aroma: the walnut, the vinegar, the herbs. Outside Georgia, about two pieces per person beside the main dish is plenty.

If you like the walnuts here, satsivi, chicken dressed in a walnut sauce, is the natural next step when you want one more dish with walnuts. And on days you want bread with your appetizer, try khachapuri, the cheese bread.

How to make satsivi

How to make khachapuri

Food safety and allergens

Because you do not reheat after mixing in the raw herbs and onion, wash your hands, cutting board and utensils well, and wash the herbs under running water. Do not serve pkhali to anyone with a walnut allergy, and check the labels of what you serve alongside, such as wheat in the bread.

Caution

Walnuts are a nut that can cause allergic reactions. Check the allergies of those eating and the labels on the products. If you use tools or a cutting board that have ground nuts on them, watch for cross-contact. Other nuts are not a safe substitute for walnuts. Use spices sold for food, and do not use ornamental flowers or wild plants whose species you cannot confirm.

Caution

Keep the refrigerator at or below 39°F (4°C). Food that needs refrigeration should not sit at room temperature for more than 2 hours. Above 90°F (32°C), refrigerate it within 1 hour. Count the cooling time, the mixing and the time after plating together as time at room temperature. Put it in a shallow container and move it to the refrigerator promptly.

Refrigerated storage

Make only as much as you can finish, and eat it the same day or the next. Keep it covered in the refrigerator and take out only what you will eat, using clean utensils. Pkhali left out at room temperature for a long time is not made safe by chilling it again. Keep it out of the freezer, too; freezing changes the texture of the leaves and nuts.

Nutrition

The whole batch is about 1028 kcal, 1.5 oz (39.2 g) protein, 3 oz (81.6 g) fat and 2.25 oz (61.2 g) carbohydrate, and one appetizer serving is about 257 kcal. The figures leave out the optional ground coriander, and onion size, spice rounding and the salt in the cooking water all change them.

Sources