Khoya paneer: cubes of paneer in a tomato and khoya curry
Serves4 servings
CuisineIndian

Khoya Paneer: Indian Paneer Curry with Fresh Tomato and Khoya

How to make khoya paneer for 4: paneer cubes simmered in a curry of strained fresh tomato and khoya cooked in ghee with whole cardamom and cloves. Covers the difference between khoya and paneer, how this tomato version differs from a cashew-and-curd version of the same name, each cooking stage, fixes for common slips, and general guidance for leftovers.

Level: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 11

Score the tomatoes

Making a shallow cross-cut on the top of a ripe red tomato for peeling
A shallow cross on top makes the skin easy to lift after blanching

Make a shallow cross-cut on the top of each of the 6 tomatoes.

STEP 22 / 11

Blanch and peel

Peeling a tomato after lifting it out of the water following a 30-second blanch
After 30 seconds in boiling water, the skin lifts away from the cross-cut

Lower the tomatoes into boiling water for 30 seconds. Lift them out and peel off the skins.

STEP 33 / 11

Chop and cook the tomatoes

Finely chopped tomatoes cooking in a saucepan until soft
Cook the chopped tomatoes until they collapse into a soft pulp

Chop the peeled tomatoes finely. Cook them for 8–10 minutes, until soft and pulpy.

STEP 44 / 11

Puree and strain

Pressing the cooked tomatoes, pureed smooth, through a sieve
The sieve holds back seeds and bits of skin

Puree the cooked tomatoes, then press the puree through a fine-mesh sieve so it is smooth and free of seeds.

STEP 55 / 11

Prepare the paneer and khoya

Paneer cut into 1-inch cubes beside khoya being mashed smooth
Have the paneer cubes and smooth khoya ready before heating the ghee

Cut the paneer into 1-inch cubes. Mash the khoya until smooth.

STEP 66 / 11

Crackle the whole spices in ghee

Sautéing green cardamom and cloves in warm ghee
Two cardamom pods and four cloves in the ghee

Heat the ghee in a pan. Add the 2 green cardamom pods and 4 cloves and cook for 30 seconds, until they crackle.

STEP 77 / 11

Cook the khoya until slightly pink

Sautéing khoya in the spiced ghee until slightly pink
Stop at a faint pink; the khoya should not darken

Add the khoya and cook, stirring, until it turns slightly pink.

STEP 88 / 11

Add the ginger and green chili pastes

Stirring ginger and green chili pastes into the cooked khoya
The pastes go in after the khoya, not before

Add the ginger paste and green chili paste and cook for a couple of minutes.

STEP 99 / 11

Add the tomato puree and paneer, then simmer

Tomato puree, black pepper, cumin, salt, water and paneer simmering together over low heat
Add the tomato puree, black pepper, cumin, salt, water and paneer at this step

Add the strained tomato puree, black pepper powder, cumin powder, rock salt to taste, 1/2 cup water and the paneer cubes. Stir, bring to a boil, then lower the heat and simmer for 10 minutes.

STEP 1010 / 11

Finish with cream and ground cardamom

Adding cream to the simmered tomato and khoya curry
Cream and ground cardamom go in together, for a final 2 minutes

Stir in the cream and cardamom powder and cook for 2 minutes.

STEP 1111 / 11

Turn off the heat and garnish

Scattering coriander leaves over the finished khoya paneer
Coriander leaves and ginger juliennes go on after the heat is off

Turn off the heat. Garnish with coriander leaves and ginger juliennes.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Paneer 200 g Cut into 1-inch cubes; simmered in the curry
Khoya (khoa / mawa), plain and unsweetened 1/2 cup Mashed smooth, then cooked in ghee until slightly pink
Large ripe red tomatoes 6 Blanched, peeled, cooked and strained into the curry base
Ginger paste 1 tsp Cooked after the khoya
Green chili paste 1 tsp Cooked after the khoya
Desi ghee 1 tbsp For the whole spices and the khoya
Black pepper powder 1 tsp Added with the tomato puree
Cumin powder 1 tsp Added with the tomato puree
Green cardamom (whole) 2 Crackled in the ghee at the start
Cloves (whole) 4 Crackled in the ghee at the start
Cardamom powder 1 tsp Added with the cream at the end
Cream 2 tbsp Stirred in at the end
Water 1/2 cup Added with the tomato puree and paneer
Rock salt (sendha namak) To taste Added with the tomato puree
Ginger, cut into juliennes A little Garnish
Coriander leaves A little Garnish
0 / 0

Six ripe red tomatoes, scored and slipped into boiling water for 30 seconds, come out with their skins ready to peel. They are cooked down until soft and pulpy, then pureed and pressed through a sieve. Meanwhile, whole green cardamom and cloves crackle in ghee, and smooth-mashed khoya goes into the pan until it takes on a faint pink color. Khoya paneer is a curry from India built on the two dairy products in its name. Here it is made with a fresh tomato base, cubes of paneer and a finish of cream and ground cardamom, and it serves 4.

About Khoya Paneer

Khoya and paneer are different dairy products, and this dish uses both. Khoya, also written khoa and also called mawa, is milk that has been partially dehydrated until only concentrated milk solids are left. Paneer is milk coagulated with heat and acid, then drained and pressed into a fresh cheese. In the curry the khoya melts into the sauce, while the paneer stays in cubes.

There is also a cashew-and-curd khoya paneer, which shares the name and some ingredients but is really a different dish. Boiled cashews are ground to a paste, green chillies and cardamom crackle in desi ghee, and the cashew paste, whisked curd and salt cook for 10 minutes. The khoya and paneer go in at the end. It uses 1 lb (500 g) paneer with ginger and coriander and serves 2. If that's the style you want, cook it as its own recipe. The tomato version below has no cashews or curd.

The tomato version takes 20 minutes to prepare and 15 minutes to cook. It is an intermediate recipe, mostly because the order in which things go into the pan matters.

Ingredients (Serves 4)

The ingredients for khoya paneer: paneer, khoya, six ripe red tomatoes, ginger and green chili pastes, ghee, spices, cream, water, salt, and ginger and coriander for garnish
Paneer, khoya, six large ripe tomatoes, pastes, ghee, whole and ground spices, cream and garnish

Keep the whole cardamom and the ground cardamom separate, and keep the ginger paste separate from the ginger cut for garnish. Each goes in at a different stage.

Equipment

  • Paring knife and cutting board
  • Pot of boiling water and a slotted spoon
  • Saucepan for cooking the tomatoes
  • Blender or other tool for pureeing
  • Fine-mesh sieve and a bowl
  • Small bowl and spoon for mashing the khoya
  • Pan or kadai for the curry
  • Spatula

Choosing Khoya, Paneer and Tomatoes

Khoya: Look for plain, unsweetened khoya at an Indian grocery, where it may also be labeled mawa or khoa. Condensed milk and cream cheese are different products and won't work in its place.

Paneer: Cut the 200 g of paneer into 1-inch cubes before you start the curry, so they are ready when it's time to add them.

Tomatoes: Use six large, ripe, red tomatoes. If you're short on time, 1/2 cup of ready tomato puree can stand in for them. Use one or the other, never both.

Salt: The recipe uses rock salt, sendha namak, added to taste along with the tomato puree.

Dairy and hot equipment

This dish contains milk in three forms: paneer, khoya and cream. Keep paneer, khoya and cream refrigerated according to their package instructions until you use them. Take care with the pot of boiling water when blanching the tomatoes and with the hot ghee when the whole spices crackle.

Method: From Fresh Tomatoes to a Finished Curry

Two parts

Steps 1–4 turn the tomatoes into a smooth puree. Step 5 gets the paneer and khoya ready. Steps 6–11 build the curry in one pan.

Common Problems with Khoya Paneer

Most slips in this recipe come down to timing, meaning what goes into the pan and when. Before you turn on the heat, line up the ingredients in the order of steps 6–10, with the whole cardamom pods and the ground cardamom in separate bowls.

What happened Likely cause What to do
The puree has bits of skin or seeds Not strained, or the sieve was too coarse Press it through a fine-mesh sieve again before step 9
The tomatoes are still in chunks Not cooked long enough to turn pulpy Keep cooking until soft and pulpy before pureeing
The khoya is darkening past pink Cooked too long in the ghee Add the pastes as soon as it turns slightly pink
The ground cardamom went in with the whole spices The two cardamoms were mixed up Whole pods go in at step 6 and the powder at step 10; keep them in separate bowls next time
Unsure about salt No fixed amount Add rock salt a little at a time in step 9 and taste
You added ready puree as well as fresh tomatoes Two tomato options were combined Use only one tomato base

Storing Leftover Khoya Paneer

Don't leave the finished curry sitting out at room temperature. Using clean utensils, divide the leftovers into shallow containers so they cool quickly, then refrigerate them. Reheat the curry thoroughly before eating.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between khoya and paneer?

Khoya (also khoa or mawa) is milk that has been partially dehydrated. Paneer is milk coagulated with heat and acid, then drained and pressed. That's why the khoya melts into the sauce while the paneer holds its shape.

Why are there two kinds of cardamom?

They do two different jobs. The whole green cardamom pods crackle in the ghee at the start to flavor the fat, and the ground cardamom goes in with the cream at the end.

Is the 30 seconds in boiling water a food-safety step?

No. The quick blanch only loosens the tomato skins so they peel off easily. It has nothing to do with making the dish safe to eat.

Sources

  • Pankaj Bhadouria, "Khoya Paneer," Pankaj Bhadouria official recipe site. The recipe followed here: the dish described as paneer cubes in a khoya and tomato based curry, 4 servings, the ingredients and amounts, the ready tomato puree alternative, the order of steps and each stage's time, and the listed 20 minutes preparation, 15 minutes cooking and intermediate level. https://www.pankajbhadouria.com/khoya-paneer
  • NDTV Food, "Khoya Paneer Recipe," credited to Gurpreet Singh, Punjab Grill. A separate recipe under the same name, using cashew nuts, curd, paneer, khoya and green cardamom for 2 servings; used only for comparison. https://food.ndtv.com/recipe-khoya-paneer-951305
  • Kaushik Khamrui, "Technology of Khoa, Chhana and Paneer," in Online Training for Master Trainers on Dairy Processing, ICAR-National Dairy Research Institute (ICAR-NDRI), Karnal, 2020; hosted by NIFTEM-T. Used only for the definitions of khoa (khoya, mawa) and paneer. https://niftem-t.ac.in/olapp/pmfme/upload/mt_handbook_milk.pdf
  • Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (Japan), "家庭での食中毒予防" (Preventing food poisoning at home). General household guidance on refrigerating chilled foods, avoiding long room-temperature holding, cooling leftovers in shallow containers and reheating thoroughly. https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/seisakunitsuite/bunya/kenkou_iryou/shokuhin/syokuchu/01_00008.html