Shor nakhod, warm chickpeas and potatoes in a bowl topped with a vivid green cilantro sauce
Prep15 min
Cook25 min
Serves4 servings
CuisineAfghan

Shor Nakhod: Afghan Street-Stall Chickpeas with Cilantro Sauce

Shor nakhod is an Afghan street-stall dish of chickpeas and boiled potatoes in a green cilantro, garlic and vinegar sauce. Covers sauce thickness and serving.

Total: 40 minLevel: Beginner

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 5

Boil the potatoes

Boiling unpeeled potatoes in a pot and checking tenderness with a bamboo skewer
Boil 15–20 minutes, until a skewer slides smoothly to the center

Wash the potatoes well with their skins on, put them in a pot and pour in water to cover. Set over medium heat, and once it boils, lower the heat slightly and boil 15–20 minutes. When a bamboo skewer slides all the way to the center without resistance, they are done. Drain in a colander.

STEP 22 / 5

Peel and cut into bite-size pieces

Peeling boiled potatoes and cutting them into 2 cm cubes
Peel, then cut into 2 cm cubes or half-moons 5 mm thick

When the potatoes have cooled enough to handle, wait about 5 minutes, then peel. Skins slip off more easily while hot, so you may also peel while holding them in a cloth. Cut into 1 inch (2 cm) cubes, or into half-moons 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick. Cubes are easy to scoop up with the beans, and thin slices soak up the sauce well.

STEP 33 / 5

Blend the cilantro sauce

Blending cilantro, garlic and vinegar in a blender into a smooth green sauce
Blend about 1 minute, until there are no grains and it flows thickly

Cut off the hard base of the cilantro and roughly chop it. In a blender put the cilantro, 2 cloves garlic, 2 tbsp distilled vinegar, 1/2 tsp salt, and 1 green chili if making it hot, and blend about 1 minute. If the sauce is so thick the blade spins in the air, add water 1 tbsp at a time while blending, and it is done when it is free of grains and flows thickly. Taste 1 tsp to check the salt and acidity.

STEP 44 / 5

Warm the chickpeas in their liquid

Warming chickpeas with their canning liquid in a small pot until steam rises
Medium heat for 3–4 minutes, until the liquid bubbles and steam rises

Put the chickpeas with their canning liquid in a small pot and warm over medium heat for 3–4 minutes. It is enough when the liquid bubbles and steam rises from the beans. If you want a warm shor nakhod like the stall's, add the potatoes to the pot here and warm them together for about 1 minute. If you want to eat it like a cold salad, you can skip this step.

STEP 55 / 5

Toss with the sauce and serve

Tossing chickpeas and potatoes with green cilantro sauce and serving in a bowl
Mix for about 30 seconds, until the sauce coats everything evenly

Move the warmed chickpeas with their liquid to a large bowl, add the potatoes and mix lightly. Pour over the cilantro sauce and fold from the bottom with a rubber spatula for about 30 seconds, so that the sauce coats the beans and potatoes evenly all over. Serve in bowls, with a little hot sauce on top if you like, and eat warm.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Chickpeas and potatoes

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Chickpeas (canned) 1 can (about 14 oz (400 g), with the liquid) If dried, cook about 5.5 oz (160 g)
Potatoes 8 oz (225 g) (2 medium) Waxy potatoes hold their shape better
2 / 2

Cilantro sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Cilantro 1 bunch (about 1 oz (30 g)) Use leaves and stems
Garlic 2 cloves —
Distilled vinegar 2 tbsp Rice vinegar also works
Salt 1/2 tsp Add more to taste
Green chili 1 Only if you want heat. Hot if used with its seeds
Water 1–3 tbsp Add if the sauce is too thick
0 / 0

On a street corner in Afghanistan, a stall is stacked with big pots, and when the seller lifts a lid, chickpeas and potatoes sway in the steam. They ladle out a bowl, pour on a generous spoonful of green sauce, add a dab of red hot sauce if you want it, and hand it over. You get the sharp smell of garlic and vinegar and the green smell of cilantro all at once. This is shor nakhod, a snack of hearty beans and potatoes under a bright, sour herb sauce, sold on street corners and in parks across Afghanistan.

Shor Nakhod at the Afghan Street Stall

A seller at an Afghan street stall ladling chickpeas and potatoes from a big pot into a bowl and pouring on green sauce

"Nakhod" is the Dari (Afghan Persian) word for chickpea. Shor nakhod is a staple at the stalls lining Afghan streets and parks, and when there's a queue, sellers put bowls together at assembly-line speed. If you know the Indian street food chana chaat, a sour chickpea salad, you'll find this one familiar.

The sauce matters more than the beans or the potatoes. It's cilantro and garlic ground smooth with white vinegar and a little olive oil. Sellers pour it on just before eating, and as the hot beans and potatoes cool, they soak up its sourness and aroma.

Did you know

Besides the green sauce, it is the stall convention to add a little hot sauce made with red chilies. Only those who want heat put it on their own bowls and adjust, so a single pot meets everyone's preference.

People make it at home too, and Afghan-American cooks in the United States each have their own proportions. Some add more potato and serve it like a salad, while others mash everything into a dip. They all keep cilantro, garlic and vinegar. As long as you have those three, the bowl will smell like the street stall.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Canned chickpeas, potatoes, cilantro, garlic, vinegar, green chili and salt for shor nakhod

Caution

This dish contains no major allergens, but chickpeas are legumes. People with an allergy to legumes should be careful. After chopping green chili, wash your hands well so you don't touch your eyes or face.

Choosing Ingredients for Shor Nakhod

Canned chickpeas, potatoes, cilantro, garlic, distilled vinegar and green chili

You can find almost everything at a supermarket. Canned chickpeas are convenient, and the recipe uses their liquid too. If you start from dried chickpeas, soak them overnight, cook them until soft and save a little of the cooking liquid.

Buy a generous bunch of cilantro. The stems have plenty of aroma, so cut off only the hard base and put leaves and stems together into the sauce. For the vinegar, plain distilled vinegar is closest to white vinegar. Rice vinegar gives a mellower sauce, and apple cider vinegar brings a fruity aroma and softer acidity.

Tip

If someone dislikes the aroma of cilantro, replace half the cilantro with flat-leaf parsley. It keeps the green color while softening the aroma. Adding a little mint also goes well.

Waxy potatoes are the best choice because they hold their shape when boiled. Floury potatoes lose their corners when you mix them, and they thicken the sauce, which is delicious in its own way.


How to make shor nakhod

Including the time to boil the potatoes, it takes about 40 minutes in all. Making the cilantro sauce while the potatoes boil gets it done quickly.

Tip

Adding the sauce right before eating, as at the stall, keeps the color of the cilantro vivid. If left a while after making, the vinegar dulls the cilantro's green, but flavor soaks into the beans and potatoes in exchange. Decide when to add the sauce according to when you will eat.

Caution

Once opened, don't store canned chickpeas in the can; move what you won't use to a storage container and refrigerate. Because the dressed shor nakhod uses raw garlic and cilantro, don't leave it long at room temperature, and refrigerate promptly what you can't finish.

Serving and Variations

A bowl of warm shor nakhod with a little red hot sauce on top, and flatbread
While warm, with a little red hot sauce on top if you like

The stalls serve shor nakhod warm, but at home people eat it warm or cold. Chilling mellows the acidity, which makes it an easy salad for a hot day. The stall hot sauce is red chilies ground with garlic and vinegar. A store-bought chili sauce works instead, or crushed red pepper dissolved in a little vinegar.

With flatbread it makes a light lunch. On an Afghan feast table it gives you something fresh between richer dishes. For a meal that feels like an Afghan table, serve it with ashak (in Japanese), herb dumplings filled with leeks and scallions and boiled; Kabuli palaw (in Japanese), the celebration rice topped with raisins and carrots; and Afghan salad (in Japanese) of chopped tomato and cucumber.

Did you know

The green sauce of shor nakhod goes well not only with beans and potatoes but also served beside grilled meat or fried food. If you make extra, it can serve as a refreshing condiment at another day's table.

A dish using boiled cauliflower in place of potatoes, dressed with a cilantro and mint sauce

Boiled cauliflower is a popular swap for the potato. Divide 1/2 head cauliflower into florets and boil in salted water for 3–4 minutes, until the core still has a little bite. A handful of mint leaves blended into the sauce with the cilantro makes it fresher, and thin slices of red chili on top make it look festive.

You can also turn it into a dip. Drain the chickpeas, blend them with the potatoes and cilantro sauce, then add olive oil a little at a time at the end until it's smooth. Aim for just sour enough, and serve it as an appetizer with flatbread or raw vegetables for dipping.

FAQ

Leftover shor nakhod put in a storage container and refrigerated

Can I make it ahead?

Once it's dressed, keep shor nakhod in a covered container in the refrigerator and finish it by the next day. The cilantro dulls in color and loses its aroma as it sits. If you're making it ahead, refrigerate the beans and potatoes separately from the sauce and combine them right before eating.

Shouldn't I discard the canning liquid?

Keep it. The liquid gives the sauce a little body and deepens the bean flavor. If it tastes too salty to you, pour off about half before using it, and if you don't have enough, add a little water.

Sources