Phở bò with boiling beef-bone broth poured in, showing flat rice noodles, thin slices of beef, scallions and cilantro
Serves8 servings
CuisineVietnamese

Phở Bò: Vietnamese Beef Noodle Soup with Charred Aromatics and Bone Broth

How to make phở bò, Vietnamese beef noodle soup, from Andrea Nguyen's 8-serving family recipe: charring onion and ginger, blanching beef bones, a 3-hour broth, soaking flat rice noodles, and building each bowl. Includes a home option that fully cooks the thin beef in a separate pot, plus shopping for bánh phở, fish sauce and rock sugar, northern and southern garnishes, storage, and allergy notes.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 7

Char the onions and ginger

Onions and ginger being charred over a gas flame
Char only the outer skin, then rinse off the black parts before they go into the pot

Set the 2 broth onions and the 4-inch piece of ginger on a grill rack or directly over a gas flame. Turn them with tongs for about 15 minutes. You are charring the skins, not turning the whole thing to charcoal. Stop when the skins are blistered and blackened in patches, the onions and ginger have softened slightly, and you smell a sweet aroma. Run the range hood and open a window while you work.

Let them cool. Rinse off the blackened skin and trim any burnt ends. Peel the ginger: if the skin has puffed up and loosened, press it off with the flat of a knife; if not, peel it with a paring knife. Rinse off any charred bits.

STEP 22 / 7

Blanch the bones and rinse

Blanched beef bones being rinsed under running water
Discard the first blanching water completely and rinse both the bones and the pot

Put the bones in the large pot with enough cold water to cover them. Bring to a boil over high heat and boil for 2–3 minutes. Pour off all the water, rinse the bones in warm water, and wash the pot. This keeps the scum and debris from the first boil out of the broth you will actually drink. The aromatics give the broth its fragrance; this blanching step is a separate job that cleans the bones.

STEP 33 / 7

Simmer the broth and the beef

Beef bones, charred onion, ginger and spices simmering gently while scum is skimmed
Keep the bubbles small and calm, and skim the surface as scum rises

Return the bones to the clean pot, add the 6 quarts (5.7 liters) of water, and bring to a boil. Lower the heat to a gentle simmer and skim off the scum that rises. Add the charred onions and ginger, star anise, cloves, cinnamon, the pieces of boneless beef, the salt, fish sauce and yellow rock sugar. Simmer uncovered.

After about 1½ hours, check the beef. Take it out once it is cooked enough to eat but before it turns tough. Put it in clean cold water for 10 minutes to keep it from drying out and darkening. Then let it cool and refrigerate it, using clean tools and containers. Keep the broth at a gentle simmer for 3 hours in total. Don't let it boil hard the whole time.

STEP 44 / 7

Strain and season the broth

Simmered beef-bone broth being poured through a fine-mesh strainer into another pot
Bones and spent aromatics stay in the strainer, and the broth goes into a clean pot

Pour the broth through a fine-mesh strainer into a second clean pot. If you like, pick out the tendon from the bones to add to the bowls. Skim off the fat if you prefer.

Taste and adjust. Season the broth a little strong on its own, because the noodles and toppings are unseasoned. If it tastes too strong, dilute it with water. The broth yields about 4 quarts (3.8 liters).

If you are making the broth a day ahead, cool it in shallow, clean containers and refrigerate it. Don't leave the whole pot at room temperature overnight. The next day, lift off the fat that has set on top before reheating.

STEP 55 / 7

Prepare the noodles

Soaked flat rice noodles being lifted from boiling water and drained
Blanch one portion at a time, just until the stiffness is gone

For dried noodles, soak them in hot tap water for 15–20 minutes, until soft and opaque, then drain. For fresh noodles, loosen the strands and give them a quick rinse in cold water.

Just before serving, dip one portion at a time into a pot of boiling water. Lift it out after 10–20 seconds, once the noodles lose their stiffness. Follow the package directions if they differ. Put the noodles in a bowl. Fill each bowl about one quarter to one third with noodles.

While the noodles soak, prepare the bowl toppings. Thinly slice the bowl onion and soak it in cold water for 30 minutes. Slice the scallion greens and chop the cilantro. Freeze the raw beef for 15 minutes so it is easier to slice. Then slice it across the grain about 1/16 inch thick, keeping it apart from cooked food.

STEP 66 / 7

Cook the thin beef, top the bowls, and pour

Thin slices of beef cooking in broth in a separate small saucepan
Cook the thin beef fully in a separate pot, and judge doneness by temperature and time, not by color

Thinly slice the simmered beef. If it is cold, dip it for a few seconds in a separate pot of hot water.

For the thin-sliced raw beef, cook it fully first. Ladle some broth into a separate small saucepan and cook the beef in it until the center reaches 167°F (75°C) and has held there for at least 1 minute. Move the cooked beef onto the noodles with clean tongs, never the ones you used for raw beef.

Arrange both kinds of beef over the noodles. Drain the soaked onion and scatter it on top, along with the scallions, cilantro and black pepper.

Flat rice noodles topped with simmered beef, fully cooked thin beef, onion, scallions and cilantro
Before the broth goes in, place each topping separately over the noodles

Bring the broth to a full boil and taste it once more. Ladle it evenly over the beef in each bowl and serve right away.

Neither the color of the meat nor pouring boiling broth over it is a reliable sign that the beef is safe. Cook the thin beef fully in a separate pot first.

Hot beef-bone broth being ladled into a bowl of rice noodles and fully cooked beef
Pour broth at a full boil evenly over the beef, then serve straight away
STEP 77 / 7

Serve the garnishes on the side

Finished beef pho on the table with lime, red chilies, bean sprouts, mint and basil on side plates
Garnishes stay on their own plate so each person can taste the broth before adding them

If you are using bean sprouts, dip them in the boiling noodle water for 30 seconds. Lift them out once they soften slightly but still have some crunch. Put the sprouts, mint, Thai basil, sawtooth herb, chilies and lime on a separate plate. Each person tastes the broth first, then adds herbs, heat and acidity as they like.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Yellow onions, for the broth (yellow onion) 2 medium, about 1 lb total Broth. Charred whole for a sweet aroma
Ginger (ginger) 4-inch piece, about 4 oz Broth. Charred with the onions, then peeled
Beef soup bones (marrow and knuckle bones) 5–6 lb Broth. Bones with marrow and joints form the body of the broth
Water 6 US quarts (5.7 liters) Broth. The simmering water for the pot
Star anise (star anise) 5 whole (about 40 points in total) Broth. Aroma. Use whole pods, not ground
Whole cloves (whole cloves) 6 Broth. Aroma
Cinnamon stick (cinnamon stick) 3-inch piece Broth. Aroma
Boneless beef: chuck, rump, brisket or cross rib roast 1⅓ lb, trimmed Broth and topping. Cut into pieces about 2 × 4 inches, simmered, then sliced
Fine sea salt 1½ tbsp Broth. Saltiness
Fish sauce (nước mắm) 4 tbsp Broth. Salt and savory depth. Contains fish
Yellow rock sugar (đường phèn) 1 oz Broth. Rounds out the flavor
Flat rice noodles (bánh phở; also sold as rice sticks) 1½–2 lb, dried or fresh Bowl. Noodles about ⅛ inch wide
Raw beef: eye of round, sirloin, London broil or tri-tip ½ lb Bowl. Sliced across the grain about 1/16 inch thick
Yellow onion, for the bowls (yellow onion) 1 medium Bowl. Thinly sliced and soaked in cold water for 30 minutes. Separate from the broth onions
Scallions (scallion) 3–4 Bowl. Green parts only, thinly sliced
Cilantro (cilantro) ⅓ cup, chopped Bowl. Topping
Black pepper To taste Bowl. Finishing
Spearmint (húng lủi), Thai or Asian basil (húng quế), sawtooth herb (ngò gai) As desired, each Side plate. Optional
Bean sprouts About ½ lb Side plate. Optional
Red chilies and lime As desired Side plate. Each person adjusts heat and acidity
0 / 0

The day starts with charring. Whole onions and a thick piece of ginger turn over a flame until their skins blister and blacken. Beef bones get a quick boil in a cold pot, and the cloudy water goes down the drain. Then the bones go back into fresh water with star anise, cloves and cinnamon, and for about three hours the pot needs only a low simmer and a ladle to skim the surface. The real finish happens at the very end, one bowl at a time: flat rice noodles, sliced beef, onion and herbs, and a ladle of broth at a full boil. This is phở bò, the beef version of Vietnam's famous noodle soup, built on a beef-bone broth that tastes clean and warmly spiced.

What Phở Bò Is and Where It Comes From

The noodle and the beef

The word phở means the noodle itself, bánh phở, a flat rice noodle. Phở bò is the bowl built on beef. Its close relative phở gà is built on chicken, with a broth of its own, and bún bò Huế is a separate Vietnamese beef noodle soup. Star anise, cloves and cinnamon are the usual spices in the broth. In Vietnam, phở is eaten at breakfast and also later in the day.

This bowl uses two kinds of beef. One is a roast-style cut that simmers in the broth and gets sliced afterward. The other is a separate cut sliced paper-thin. At the table it comes with a side plate of bean sprouts, herbs, chili and lime, the generous plate you'd find in the south.

History and regional bowls

Phở was born in Nam Định, and Hanoi is the city most closely tied to it. Beef bones came into use in the late 19th century, and by the 1930s street vendors were selling phở. After 1954 the dish spread to the south, where the broth got sweeter and more herbs and condiments were added.

Hanoi-style phở still has a clear broth and spare garnishes, while southern bowls arrive with plenty of herbs and bean sprouts. Street stalls all work the same way: hot broth goes over rice noodles and meat, and each customer adds their own garnishes. The last step of this recipe follows that routine. For a different Vietnamese noodle meal, try bún chả, or browse more dishes from Vietnam.

Planning the day

You can make the broth a day ahead. While it simmers, prepare the noodles, sliced beef and garnishes.

Ingredients: Serves 8, from a Single Recipe

Phở bò ingredients: beef bones, beef, flat rice noodles, onions, ginger, star anise, cloves, cinnamon and fish sauce
Bones, two kinds of beef, flat rice noodles, aromatics, whole spices, fish sauce, salt and yellow rock sugar

The broth makes about 4 quarts (3.8 liters), enough for 8 servings.

Water and seasoning not counted in the table

The 6 quarts (5.7 liters) in the table is only the broth water. The water for blanching the bones, the warm water for rinsing them, the water for soaking and boiling the noodles, the cold water for the sliced onion, and the clean water for the simmered beef are all separate, and none of it comes out of the 6 quarts. Any salt, fish sauce, rock sugar or water you add when seasoning the strained broth is also extra, on top of the starting amounts.

Allergy and cross-contact

Fish sauce is made from fish. Check labels for beef and for any herbs you are sensitive to. Allergens can also travel through shared tools, cooking water and serving plates. Keep tongs, boards and plates for raw beef separate from anything used for cooked food, noodles or herbs.

Equipment

  • A stockpot of at least 12 US quarts (about 11.4 liters) capacity. Don't try to squeeze 8 servings into a smaller pot.
  • A grill rack or gas burner and long tongs for charring the onions and ginger. Use the range hood and open a window.
  • A paring knife for peeling the charred ginger.
  • A colander for draining and rinsing the blanched bones.
  • A ladle for skimming and serving.
  • A fine-mesh strainer and a second clean pot for the strained broth.
  • A large bowl for soaking the dried noodles, and a long-handled wire strainer for blanching portions.
  • A small separate saucepan for cooking the thin-sliced beef.
  • A food thermometer, if you want to check the center temperature of the thin beef.
  • Shallow, clean containers for cooling and storing broth, with enough room in the refrigerator for them.

Shopping and Substitutions for Phở Bò

Most of the list is easy to find at an ordinary supermarket: onions, ginger, a roast-style beef cut, a lean cut for slicing thin, scallions, cilantro, bean sprouts, chilies, limes, sea salt and black pepper. Whole star anise, cloves and cinnamon sticks are often on the spice shelf too.

A few things are worth a trip to a butcher, a Southeast Asian grocery or an import shop:

  • Beef soup bones. Use marrow and knuckle bones. Other bones, such as shank bones, change the mix and the taste of the broth.
  • Bánh phở. Look for flat rice noodles about ⅛ inch wide, dried or fresh. Rice vermicelli is round in cross-section and has a different texture, so it makes a different bowl.
  • Fish sauce. It gives the broth its saltiness and savory depth, and soy sauce won't do the same job. If you leave it out because of a fish allergy, expect the broth to taste different.
  • Yellow rock sugar (đường phèn). Asian grocers carry it. White sugar is a different product, so if you use it, add a little at a time and taste.
  • Vietnamese herbs. Spearmint, Thai basil and sawtooth herb (ngò gai) can be hard to find under those names. They're optional, so serve whatever you can get. Ordinary cilantro tastes different from all of them.

Method: From Charred Aromatics to a Ladle of Boiling Broth

Reading the pot, not just the clock

Time the charring at 15 minutes, the beef at 1½ hours and the broth at 3 hours. Bone size, pot and burner change how things go. Check the state of the onion skin, the firmness of the beef and the bubbles in the pot as you go.

Troubleshooting Phở Bò

What you're after is a clean, fragrant broth and beef that comes out of the pot before it toughens. The table covers the usual problems.

Problem Likely cause What to do
Cloudy broth Blanching water not fully discarded, bones and pot not rinsed, broth boiled hard, scum not skimmed Discard the first boiling water completely and rinse both the bones and the pot. Keep the broth at a gentle simmer and skim it
Burnt, bitter aroma Onions and ginger charred until black throughout Char only the skins, then remove the blackened skin and burnt ends before they go into the pot
Broth too strong or salty Seasoning concentrated, or too much added while adjusting Dilute with water. Taste again once the noodles and toppings are in the bowl
Simmered beef is tough Left in the pot too long Check the beef from about 1½ hours. Take it out when it is cooked enough to eat, before it toughens
Noodles break or go soggy Blanched too long, or boiled too early After soaking, blanch one portion at a time just before eating, and check the package directions

Serving, Variations and Storage

Ways to serve it

Put each bowl together right before it's eaten, so the noodles stay soft and the broth goes in at a full boil. For a simpler, Hanoi-style bowl, top it with just scallion, cilantro, onion and pepper and skip the side plate. For the full southern spread, set out extra bean sprouts, Thai basil, mint, sawtooth herb, chili and lime, and let everyone build their own bowl. If you'd rather skip the thin raw beef, top the bowls with the sliced simmered beef alone.

Storing and reheating

Only assemble the bowls you'll eat right away, and store the broth, meat and noodles separately. To cool the broth quickly, divide it into shallow, clean containers and refrigerate it. Don't leave the big pot sitting at room temperature for long. The cooked beef also goes into a clean container in the refrigerator.

Soups and stews with meat keep in the refrigerator for 3–4 days at 39°F (4°C) or below. For longer storage, freeze them at −64°F (−18°C) or below for 2–3 months. Reheat to 167°F (75°C) or above and bring the soup to a boil. Cook fresh noodles for each serving.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I prepare dried rice noodles?

Soak them in hot tap water for 15–20 minutes, until soft and opaque, then drain. Just before serving, dip one portion at a time in boiling water for 10–20 seconds. Follow the package directions where they differ.

Can I make the broth a day ahead?

Yes. Cool the strained broth in shallow containers and refrigerate it. Lift off the set fat, then reheat the broth until it boils.

I'm not a fan of star anise. Can I change it?

Stick with 5 whole pods. Using fewer changes the aroma of the broth, and ground star anise is no substitute for whole pods.

I'm uneasy about pouring broth over raw beef. What should I do?

Follow step 6. Cook the thin slices in a separate small pot of broth until the center reaches 167°F (75°C) and stays there for at least 1 minute, then move them to the bowl with clean tongs. Pouring broth over raw beef won't tell you whether the meat has reached a safe temperature. You can also top the bowls with only the simmered beef.

Sources