Curry of browned paneer and bell pepper folded into a tomato-cream gravy
Prep1 hr 30 min
Cook30 min
Serves4 servings
CuisineNorth Indian

Paneer Tikka Masala: Oven-Browned Paneer in a Tomato-Onion Cream Gravy

How to make paneer tikka masala for four, following one North Indian restaurant-style recipe: paneer, onion and bell pepper marinated in thick spiced yogurt and grilled in the oven at 200°C, then folded into a tomato-onion gravy finished with cream and kasuri methi. Covers choosing paneer, Kashmiri chilli, besan and kasuri methi, how it differs from paneer tikka and paneer butter masala, and how to avoid rubbery paneer and split yogurt.

Total: 2 hrLevel: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 10

Mix the yogurt marinade

Thick yogurt being mixed with besan and spices into a marinade
A thick, smooth marinade, before the paneer and vegetables go in

In a bowl, combine 6 tbsp hung curd or thick Greek yogurt with 1 tsp ginger-garlic paste, 1 tsp lemon juice, 1 tbsp besan, 1/2 tsp salt, 1/2 tsp Kashmiri chilli powder, 1/2 tsp coriander powder (if using), 1/2 tsp garam masala or tandoori masala, 1/4 tsp turmeric, 2–3 pinches of nutmeg and the saffron (if using). Mix until the besan has no lumps and the marinade is thick and smooth, falling slowly from the spoon.

STEP 22 / 10

Coat the paneer and vegetables, then chill

Paneer, onion and bell pepper coated in marinade, ready to be covered and chilled
Fold gently so each piece is coated and stays whole

Add the paneer cubes, the onion squares from the tikka onion and the bell pepper squares. Fold gently so every piece is lightly coated without breaking. Cover the bowl and refrigerate for at least 1 hour, or up to overnight.

STEP 33 / 10

Thread the skewers and brush with oil

Marinated paneer and vegetables threaded on skewers and brushed with oil
The paneer is still pale here; only a thin film of oil goes on

Thread paneer, onion and bell pepper alternately onto metal skewers and lay them on a lined tray. Brush 1–2 tsp oil thinly over the surface. If you use bamboo skewers instead, soak them in water for at least 10 minutes and confirm that they are suitable for oven use.

STEP 44 / 10

Grill the paneer tikka at 400°F (200°C)

Paneer on skewers under the oven's top element, picking up browned edges
Turn the skewers halfway and stop when the edges show light brown spots

Preheat the oven for at least 10 minutes. Using the top element, grill the skewers on the upper rack at 400°F (200°C) for 15–20 minutes, turning them halfway through. Take them out once light brown spots start to appear along the edges. Do not let them blacken or grill until the paneer dries out: over-grilling makes paneer dense and rubbery.

Convection microwave ovens

In a convection microwave oven, use 350°F (180°C). That is a different condition from the standard oven's 400°F (200°C) top element, and it does not apply to ordinary microwave heating.

STEP 55 / 10

Blanch the gravy onion and tomatoes

Gravy onions and tomatoes blanching briefly in salted water
Blanch briefly, then cover and leave off the heat

Bring water to a boil with a pinch of salt. Add the gravy onion, halved, and the tomatoes, and cook for 1–2 minutes. Turn off the heat, cover, and leave for 15–20 minutes. This is the gravy onion, not the one for the tikka.

STEP 66 / 10

Puree the onion and tomatoes separately

Blanched onion and tomatoes made into a separate paste and puree
Onion paste and peeled tomato puree, kept apart

Blend the onion into a paste without adding water. Peel the blanched tomatoes, then puree them separately. Keep the two in separate bowls: they go into the pan at different times.

STEP 77 / 10

Cook the onion paste, then add ginger-garlic paste

Onion paste cooked in oil, with ginger-garlic paste being added
Cook the onion paste until golden before the ginger-garlic paste goes in

Heat 2 tbsp oil in a sauté pan over medium heat and add the onion paste. Stir occasionally until it turns golden. Add 1 tsp ginger-garlic paste and keep stirring until its raw smell is gone. Don't let it burn, which turns it bitter; move on to the tomato before that happens.

STEP 88 / 10

Cook down the tomato and ground spices

Tomato puree and ground spices cooked until oil appears at the edge
Cook until a thin ring of oil separates at the edge of the pan

Add the tomato puree and cook, stirring, until oil separates and shows along the edge of the gravy. Then stir in 1/4 tsp turmeric, 1/2 tsp Kashmiri chilli powder, 1 tsp coriander powder, 1/2 tsp cumin powder (if using) and 1/2 tsp garam masala or tandoori masala. If it starts to catch on the bottom, lower the heat. Do not rush the dairy in while the mixture is still wet.

STEP 99 / 10

Stir in the yogurt off the heat, then simmer

Yogurt stirred into the gravy in a pan taken off the heat
Mix the yogurt in with the pan off the heat, then simmer

Take the pan off the heat. Whisk 2–2.5 tbsp full-fat yogurt until smooth, add it, and stir well so it blends in without splitting. Return the pan to the heat, add up to 1/2 cup water and salt to taste, and simmer over low to medium-low heat for 5–6 minutes. Aim for a medium consistency: a little oil on the surface and a sauce that leaves a thin coat on a spoon.

STEP 1010 / 10

Add cream and kasuri methi, then fold in the tikka

Grilled paneer folded into the gravy with cream and crushed kasuri methi
Fold the tikka in with the heat off so the paneer stays tender

Add 3 tbsp light cream and 1/2 tsp kasuri methi crushed between your palms, and cook over low heat for 1 minute. Taste; if the tomatoes are sharp, add 1/2–1 tsp sugar. Turn off the heat, slide the grilled paneer and vegetables off the skewers, and fold them gently into the gravy. Let the residual heat warm them; don't keep simmering. Scatter 1–2 tbsp chopped coriander leaves over the top.

Turn the heat off first, then add the tikka, to keep the paneer from overheating.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

For the paneer tikka

Ingredient Amount Role and how to choose
Paneer 9 oz (250g) Start with 9 oz (250g); up to 10.5 oz (300g) also works. Cut into roughly 1 inches (2.5 cm) cubes
Bell pepper (capsicum) 1 medium Adds sweetness and color once grilled
Onion 1 medium Separate into layers and cut into squares to thread between the paneer
Hung curd or thick Greek yogurt 6 tbsp A thick, low-moisture yogurt that clings to the pieces
Ginger-garlic paste 1 tsp For the marinade only
Lemon juice 1 tsp Lime juice also works
Kashmiri chilli powder 1/2 tsp For color and mild heat
Coriander powder 1/2 tsp, optional Can be left out
Garam masala or tandoori masala 1/2 tsp Blends vary in salt and heat; check the label
Turmeric powder 1/4 tsp Color and an earthy note
Nutmeg 2–3 pinches Ground or freshly grated
Saffron 12–15 strands, optional For aroma. Can be left out
Besan (gram flour) 1 tbsp Helps the marinade hold on. Used here instead of cornstarch, not together with it
Oil 1–2 tsp Only for brushing the skewers before grilling. A neutral oil
Salt 1/2 tsp Check whether your spice blend already contains salt
2 / 3

For the gravy

Ingredient Amount Role and how to choose
Onion 100g Or 2 medium onions. Blanched, then made into a paste on its own
Tomatoes 200g Or 3 medium tomatoes. Ripe and red. Blanched, peeled and pureed separately
Water for blanching as needed Enough to cover the onion and tomatoes. Separate from the water added to the gravy
Salt for blanching a pinch Added to the blanching water
Oil 2 tbsp For cooking the onion paste. Butter also works
Ginger-garlic paste 1 tsp For the gravy. Measured separately from the marinade
Coriander powder 1 tsp
Cumin powder 1/2 tsp, optional
Garam masala or tandoori masala 1/2 tsp
Kashmiri chilli powder 1/2 tsp Measured separately from the marinade
Turmeric powder 1/4 tsp
Plain full-fat yogurt 2–2.5 tbsp Whisked smooth. Added with the pan off the heat
Water up to 1/2 cup Added to adjust the thickness of the gravy
Light cream 3 tbsp For richness
Kasuri methi (dried fenugreek leaves) 1/2 tsp Crushed between your palms before adding
Sugar 1/2–1 tsp, optional Only if the tomatoes taste sharp
Salt to taste Taste first, since spice blends vary in salt
Coriander leaves 1–2 tbsp Chopped, to finish
3 / 3

To serve (optional)

Ingredient Amount Note
Prepared roti as needed Served on the side. Naan, chapati or paratha also suit
0 / 0

Cubes of paneer, petals of onion and squares of bell pepper go onto skewers, thickly coated in a yogurt marinade that Kashmiri chilli and turmeric turn red-orange. Under the oven's top element, small golden-brown spots start to show along the edges. In another pan, onion paste turns golden, and tomato puree and ground spices cook down until oil gathers at the rim. Then yogurt and cream soften the sauce. The grilled paneer goes into that smooth tomato-onion gravy at the very end, so it keeps its browned edges. Plan on about two hours from start to finish.

About Paneer Tikka Masala

The dish is made in two parts. Paneer tikka is the grilled paneer itself; paneer tikka masala is that tikka finished in a gravy. The tikka is marinated paneer, grilled or pan-fried, and if you stop there you have a dish in its own right. Fold it into the tomato-onion masala and it becomes a main-course curry. Cooking the parts separately is what sets it apart from paneer that has simply been simmered in sauce.

This version is a restaurant-style Punjabi curry from the North Indian kitchen. Paneer butter masala is often mentioned alongside it, but it's a separate dish. It doesn't start from grilled tikka, and its sauce is built differently. For more dishes from the same country, see India.

Ingredients for 4 Servings: Tikka and Gravy Measured Separately

Paneer, bell pepper, onions, yogurt, tomatoes, spices and the other ingredients for the gravy
Measure the tikka ingredients and the gravy ingredients as two separate sets

Several ingredients appear twice: onion, ginger-garlic paste, yogurt, oil, salt and some of the ground spices. Measure each set separately so the marinade amounts and the gravy amounts never get mixed up.

Allergens and diet

This dish contains dairy (paneer, yogurt, cream) and chickpea (besan). Check the ingredient labels of spice blends such as garam masala or tandoori masala, as well as any shared-facility statements. Roti and naan served alongside may contain wheat. The dish is vegetarian, but because it contains dairy it is not vegan.

Equipment

  • Oven with a top heating element
  • Baking tray, lined
  • Metal skewers (oven-safe)
  • Pastry brush, for the oil
  • Tongs, for turning the skewers
  • Mixing bowls
  • Small pot, for blanching
  • Blender
  • Sauté pan, for the gravy
  • Whisk or fork, for the yogurt

No tandoor or special grill is needed; a home oven works.

Choosing Ingredients and Substitutes

Paneer is an Indian fresh, unripened cheese made by heating milk and curdling it with acid. It's firm and cohesive, with a mild, slightly sweet, slightly tangy, nutty flavor. Because it holds its shape when heated instead of melting, you can marinate it, skewer it and grill it. Tofu and ordinary cheeses differ in moisture, milky flavor and browning, so paneer is the one to use. Look for it under the name "paneer" or "Indian fresh cheese."

Kashmiri chilli powder brings color with gentle heat. Sweet paprika matches the color, but not the heat or aroma. Hotter chilli powders need a smaller amount, so whatever you use, check the label and start small.

Besan (gram flour, made from chickpeas) helps the marinade cling. Cornstarch works too. Use it in place of the besan, never as well as it. Kasuri methi is dried fenugreek leaves; ground fenugreek seed is a different ingredient.

Cream: use 3 tbsp light cream, or up to 4 tbsp. With heavy cream, use 1–2 tbsp. Light cream is roughly 25–35% fat, and product names vary from country to country, so go by the fat percentage on the label.

Optional spices: you can leave out the marinade's 1/2 tsp coriander powder, the saffron, the gravy's cumin and the nutmeg. Keep the gravy's 1 tsp coriander powder. Each spice brings its own aroma, so drop them one at a time rather than swapping them all for some other spice. Paneer and spice blends also vary in salt, so taste before you season the gravy.

Method: Grill the Tikka, Build the Gravy, Bring Them Together

How the work is split

Steps 1–4 make the paneer tikka; steps 5–9 make the gravy; step 10 joins them. While the paneer marinates, you can blanch and puree the gravy vegetables.

Fixing Common Problems

Problem Likely cause What to do
The paneer is hard and rubbery Grilled too long, or simmered in the gravy after it was added Check from 15 minutes for light browning at the edges. Turn the heat off before adding the tikka to the gravy
The marinade slides off Yogurt too watery Use hung curd or a thick Greek yogurt. Besan helps it hold
The yogurt in the gravy split Cold yogurt added to a pan still on high heat Take the pan off the heat and stir in well-whisked full-fat yogurt
The tomato tastes too sharp Underripe or very acidic tomatoes Choose ripe red tomatoes. If needed, add a little of the optional sugar, tasting as you go
The kasuri methi has little aroma Dried leaves added whole Crush them finely between your fingers or palms before adding
The gravy tastes bitter Onion or ginger-garlic paste burned Watch the color in steps 7 and 8 and lower the heat before it catches

Split yogurt is the problem people hit most often, and the order of the step prevents it: take the pan off the heat, whisk the yogurt smooth, then stir it in.

Serving, Storing and Variations

Paneer tikka masala scattered with chopped coriander, with roti on the side
Finish with chopped coriander and serve with roti or another flatbread

Serve paneer tikka masala with naan, roti, chapati or paratha. A plain roti on the side is the easiest way to scoop up gravy and a grilled piece in one bite. The sugar is optional, so add it only after you've tasted the finished gravy.

No oven? Cook the marinated paneer and vegetables on a tawa, the flat griddle found in Indian kitchens. Use low-to-medium or medium heat and turn the pieces until browned. Keep this recipe's amounts, cook a few pieces at a time, and go by how brown the surface is rather than a fixed time. Neither an oven nor a pan gives you the charcoal smoke of a tandoor, but you still get the browned edges.

Cool leftovers quickly in shallow containers, and don't leave them at room temperature for long. When reheating, heat until the center reaches 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between paneer tikka and paneer tikka masala?

Paneer tikka is paneer marinated in spiced yogurt and grilled or pan-fried. Paneer tikka masala takes that tikka and folds it into a tomato-onion gravy, which makes it a curry served as a main dish.

Can I use tofu or another cheese instead of paneer?

Not as an equal swap. Paneer is an acid-set fresh cheese that keeps its shape when heated, while tofu and other cheeses differ in moisture, flavor and browning. Look for paneer under that name, or as Indian fresh cheese.

How do I keep the paneer from turning hard?

Stop grilling when the edges show light brown spots. Once it goes into the gravy, let it warm through with the heat off instead of simmering it.

Sources

  • Dassana Amit, Dassana's Veg Recipes, "Paneer Tikka Masala Recipe." The recipe followed in this article: four servings, preparation and cooking times, the marinade and gravy amounts, oven grilling at 200°C, the warning about over-grilling, the recipe's own description as restaurant-style Punjabi and North Indian, and the suggested breads. https://www.vegrecipesofindia.com/paneer-tikka-masala-recipe/
  • Neha's Cook Book, "Paneer tikka masala | how to make paneer tikka masala | paneer tikka gravy." A separately written home version cooked on a tawa, cited only to show that a pan-cooked variant exists and for its mention of the tandoor's smoky flavor; its quantities and timings are not used here. https://www.nehascookbook.com/paneer-tikka-masala-how-to-make-paneer-tikka-masala-paneer-tikka-gravy/
  • Kumar, Rai, Niranjan and Bhat, "Paneer—An Indian soft cheese variant: a review," Journal of Food Science and Technology (full text on PubMed Central). Paneer as an acid-coagulated, fresh, unripened cheese, its firm texture and flavor, and how texture varies with milk and method. Not used as evidence for the origin of paneer tikka masala. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4008736/
  • Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, Japan, "Six points for preventing food poisoning at home" (in Japanese). General home guidance on cooling food in shallow containers and heating to a center temperature of 75°C for at least 1 minute. https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/seisakunitsuite/bunya/kenkou_iryou/shokuhin/syokuchu/01_00006.html