Punjabi-style kadhi with fried methi pakodi in a bowl of golden gravy
Serves4 servings
CuisineIndian (Punjabi)

Kadhi: Punjabi Yogurt and Besan Curry with Methi Pakodi

How to make one Punjabi kadhi: fried fresh-fenugreek fritters simmered in a spiced yogurt and gram flour gravy. Follows Sanjeev Kapoor's published amounts and order, with notes on choosing ingredients, regional differences, and what to watch at the pot.

Level: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 10

Mix the pakodi batter

Fresh methi leaves prepared in a metal bowl
Fresh leaves, not dried kasuri methi

Clean the fresh methi leaves and have them ready in a bowl.

Roughly chop the medium onion.

Roughly chopping a medium onion on a board
Irregular pieces for the batter

Finely chop the ginger for the batter.

Finely chopping fresh ginger with a knife
This ginger is chopped; the ginger for the gravy is grated later

Crush the ajwain.

Crushing ajwain seeds in a small mortar
Crush the seeds before they go into the bowl

In a bowl, combine 1 cup besan, the crushed ajwain, a pinch of hing, the chopped ginger, 1 1/2 cups methi leaves, the onion, salt, 1/2 tsp red chilli powder, 1/4 tsp turmeric, a pinch of baking soda and 1/2 cup water. Mix until no dry flour remains and the batter holds together.

Folding wet besan batter with methi and onion using a spoon
Mix until the leaves and onion are spread through the batter
STEP 22 / 10

Fry the pakodi

Oil heating in a deep kadai with no food in it yet
Heat the oil before any batter goes in

Heat enough neutral oil for frying in a deep pan.

Carefully slide small portions of batter into the hot oil. Do not drop all of it in at once.

Dropping a small portion of batter into hot oil
Small portions, added carefully

Fry until golden and crisp.

Irregular pakodi frying golden in bubbling oil
Look for a golden, crisp surface

Lift them out with a slotted spoon and drain on absorbent paper.

Lifting golden pakodi onto absorbent paper with a slotted spoon
Drain the fried pakodi on paper
STEP 33 / 10

Whisk the yogurt mixture

Whisking the yogurt and besan mixture in a bowl
Whisk until smooth, with no water yet

In a separate bowl, whisk 1/2 cup yogurt, 2 tbsp besan, 2 tsp ginger-garlic paste, 1 tsp green chilli paste, 1/4 tsp turmeric and salt until smooth. Getting it smooth before any water goes in helps keep lumps down.

STEP 44 / 10

Thin it with water

Pouring water into the smooth yogurt and besan mixture
The water goes in only after the mixture is smooth

Pour in 5 cups water.

Mix until even, then set aside.

Whisking the thinned yogurt mixture until even
Mix evenly and set aside until the pot is ready
STEP 55 / 10

Sizzle the whole spices

Breaking dried red chillies by hand over a dish
Break the chillies by hand

Before heating the oil, slice the large onion and grate the ginger shown in step 6, so that nothing waits in the hot oil. Break the 2 dried red chillies.

Heat 2 tbsp oil in a deep pot, starting on gentler heat and adjusting as needed.

Neutral oil heating gently in a deep pan
Keep the heat under control, since burnt spices turn bitter

Add 1 tsp cumin seeds, 1/4 tsp fenugreek seeds, 8–10 peppercorns, 2–3 cloves and the broken chillies. Cook until fragrant, without letting them burn.

Cumin, fenugreek seeds, peppercorns, cloves and broken chillies sizzling in oil
Stop when the spices smell fragrant
STEP 66 / 10

Cook the hing, onion and ginger

Thinly slicing a large onion on a board
The large onion is sliced for the gravy

These are the large onion, thinly sliced, and the grated ginger you prepared before heating the oil.

Grating fresh ginger into a small dish
The ginger for the gravy is grated

Add a pinch of hing to the spiced oil and stir.

Adding a pinch of hing to the sizzling spiced oil
The hing goes in after the whole spices

Add the sliced onion and sauté until translucent.

Sliced onion turning translucent among whole spices in the pan
Cook until the onion is translucent

Add the grated ginger and sauté for 1 minute.

Grated ginger added to translucent onion and whole spices
One minute for the grated ginger
STEP 77 / 10

Bring the gravy to a boil

Pouring the yogurt mixture from a tilted bowl into the pan
Pour the mixture over the onion and spices

Pour the yogurt mixture into the pot and stir.

Bring to a boil over high heat, stirring and watching the bottom of the pot.

Stirring the yellow kadhi as it reaches a boil
Keep stirring across the bottom until it boils
STEP 88 / 10

Thicken a little, then add the pakodi

Yellow kadhi simmering gently and slightly thickened
Slightly thickened is enough at this point

Lower the heat and simmer until the kadhi is slightly thicker, stirring now and then. Chop the coriander for step 9 now if you have not done so.

Set a few fried pakodi aside on a small plate.

A few fried pakodi set aside on a small plate beside the batch bowl
These few are for the top of the dish

Add the remaining pakodi to the kadhi.

Fried methi pakodi added to the thickened kadhi
The rest of the pakodi go into the pot

Simmer for 2–3 minutes.

Methi pakodi simmering in golden kadhi
Two to three minutes together in the pot
STEP 99 / 10

Stir in the coriander and turn off the heat

Chopping fresh coriander leaves on a clean board
Chop the leaves small

Have 1 tbsp fresh coriander leaves chopped and ready.

Add the coriander to the hot kadhi and stir it in while the heat is still on.

Stirring chopped coriander into the hot kadhi with a ladle
The coriander goes in before the heat goes off

Turn off the heat and move the pot off the burner, using proper handles or cloths.

The finished pot of kadhi resting off the stove
Cooking ends here
STEP 1010 / 10

Serve with the reserved pakodi on top

Kadhi with methi pakodi ladled into a white bowl
Serve while hot

Ladle the kadhi and pakodi into serving bowls while hot.

Top with the reserved fried pakodi and serve. No fresh herbs are added at this stage.

Placing a reserved fried pakodi on top of a bowl of kadhi with a spoon
The only garnish is the reserved pakodi
0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Gram flour (besan), for pakodi 1 cup Body of the batter
Carom seeds (ajwain), for pakodi 1/4 tsp, crushed Aroma
Asafoetida (hing), for pakodi a pinch Aroma
Ginger, for pakodi 2 tsp, finely chopped Fresh bite in the batter
Fresh fenugreek leaves (methi), for pakodi 1 1/2 cups The leaves that define these pakodi
Onion, for pakodi 1 medium, roughly chopped Texture in the batter
Salt, for pakodi to taste Seasons the batter
Red chilli powder, for pakodi 1/2 tsp Heat
Turmeric powder, for pakodi 1/4 tsp Color and aroma
Baking soda, for pakodi a pinch Goes into the batter; food-grade only
Water, for pakodi 1/2 cup Brings the batter together
Neutral cooking oil, for pakodi as needed For frying the pakodi
Plain unsweetened yogurt, for kadhi 1/2 cup Base of the gravy
Gram flour (besan), for kadhi 2 tbsp Thickens the gravy
Ginger-garlic paste, for kadhi 2 tsp Savory depth
Green chilli paste, for kadhi 1 tsp Heat
Turmeric powder, for kadhi 1/4 tsp Color and aroma
Salt, for kadhi to taste Seasons the gravy
Water, for kadhi 5 cups Thins the yogurt mixture
Neutral cooking oil, for kadhi 2 tbsp For the whole spices and onion
Cumin seeds, for kadhi 1 tsp Whole spice for the hot oil
Fenugreek seeds (methi dana), for kadhi 1/4 tsp Whole spice for the hot oil; not the leaves
Black peppercorns, for kadhi 8–10 Whole spice for the hot oil
Cloves, for kadhi 2–3 Whole spice for the hot oil
Dried red chillies, for kadhi 2, broken Heat and aroma
Asafoetida (hing), for kadhi a pinch Aroma
Onion, for kadhi 1 large, sliced Sautéed base of the gravy
Ginger, for kadhi 1 tsp, grated Added to the onion
Fresh coriander leaves, for kadhi 1 tbsp, chopped Stirred into the hot kadhi before the heat goes off
0 / 0

Yogurt and gram flour are whisked smooth, thinned with water, and poured over onion and whole spices in a deep pot. Once the gravy has boiled and thickened a little on low heat, golden fritters flecked with fresh fenugreek leaves go in. That pairing is the whole appeal: a smooth, tangy gravy and a fritter that still has some bite. This is Punjabi Pakoda Kadhi, made here with fritters built on fresh methi leaves.

Punjabi Kadhi and Its Regional Cousins

Kadhi is a family of dishes. Regional kadhis across India differ in leaves, spices and amounts, and the Punjabi style is thicker, creamier and tangy. In Punjab it is made with onion pakora. This version swaps those for methi pakodi, so treat the onion version as its own recipe.

Punjabi kadhi chawal is kadhi paired with steamed rice or cumin rice. For more dishes from the same country, see our India page.

How it comes together

Two bowls and two pans do the work here: one for the methi pakodi, one for the yogurt and gram flour gravy. They only meet near the end, and a few fried pakodi are saved to go on top.

Ingredients for 4 Servings

Besan, methi, yogurt and spices divided into pakodi and kadhi groups
Besan, water, onion, ginger, turmeric, salt and hing each appear in both groups, so keep the portions apart

Measure each group separately. The medium onion and chopped ginger go into the batter, while the large onion and grated ginger go into the gravy. Fenugreek leaves and fenugreek seeds are different ingredients and are not interchangeable.

Allergens

This dish contains yogurt (milk) and besan (chickpea, a legume). Check the ingredient and allergen labels on store-bought ginger-garlic and green chilli pastes, and consider cross-contact in frying oil.

Equipment

  • Deep, heavy-bottomed pot for the kadhi
  • Deep pan or kadai for frying
  • Two mixing bowls, one for the batter and one for the yogurt mixture
  • Whisk
  • Slotted spoon
  • Absorbent paper
  • Small mortar and pestle
  • Knife, cutting board and grater
  • Small plate for the reserved pakodi
  • Ladle and serving bowls
  • Cooking thermometer, if you like to use one to keep an eye on frying oil

Choosing Ingredients for Kadhi

  • Besan: This is chickpea flour. Look for it at Indian grocers or online. Wheat flour won't stand in for it in the same amount.
  • Fresh methi: Indian grocers carry it fresh or frozen. Dried kasuri methi is a different ingredient with a different strength of aroma, so it doesn't swap in equal measure. Leaving the leaves out or using dried ones changes both the aroma and the moisture of the batter.
  • Ajwain: You can leave it out if you can't find it, though the flavor will change.
  • Red chilli powder: Cayenne and similar powders vary in heat, and so do dried chillies, so your kadhi may come out hotter or milder.
  • Yogurt: Use plain unsweetened store-bought yogurt, since its sourness sets the tang of the finished dish. Use it straight from the store rather than souring it at room temperature.
  • Pastes: Ginger-garlic paste can be store-bought or made separately. For green chilli paste, grind green chillies finely.
  • Coriander: If you dislike it or can't find it, leave it out; the dish will simply have less aroma.

Method: Fry First, Then Build the Gravy

Reading the photos

The photos show what each stage looks like. They are not a guide to exact quantities, temperatures or elapsed time.

The only timed moments are the minute for the grated ginger and the 2–3 minutes after the pakodi go in. Everywhere else, cook by what you see in the pot.

Kadhi Troubleshooting

What you see Likely reason What to do
Lumps in the yogurt mixture Water went in before the besan was smooth Whisk the yogurt and besan smooth first, then add the water
Sediment or scorching on the bottom Besan settling while the pot heats Stir across the bottom until it boils, and stir now and then on low heat
Foam climbing the pot The gravy can foam as it heats Use a large pot and keep stirring as it heats
Bitter-tasting spices The whole spices burned Start on gentler heat and stop once they smell fragrant
Pakodi fall apart or seem oily The batter or frying setup Fry small portions until golden and crisp, and drain them well on paper
Gravy thicker or thinner than you hoped Pots and burners differ; the 5 cups of water is the set amount Stop the low simmer at "slightly thicker" and judge again next time

Serving Kadhi and Variations

Kadhi is best served hot, soon after it's cooked. Wash your hands, keep raw and cooked foods apart, use clean utensils, and heat the gravy thoroughly.

A few changes will shift the dish in predictable ways:

Change What shifts
A tangier or milder store-bought yogurt The sourness of the gravy
Leaving out the fresh methi, or using dried The aroma and moisture of the pakodi
Leaving the pakodi in the gravy longer than 2–3 minutes They soften as they absorb gravy, giving a different dish
A different frying oil The aroma. Mustard oil is one option
Steamed rice, cumin rice or chapati alongside How rich each mouthful feels and how the meal comes together. All are optional

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between kadhi and kadhi pakoda?

Kadhi is the broader name for a yogurt and besan gravy, and regions have their own versions. Kadhi pakoda, like this Punjabi one, has fried pakodi in that gravy.

What goes in these pakodi?

Besan, fresh methi leaves, onion, ginger and spices. Other versions use onion pakora.

Why are there no curry leaves, garam masala or cream?

Some other kadhi recipes use curry leaves or garam masala, but they belong to different formulas. This one also leaves out bay leaf and extra ghee.

Can I sprinkle fresh coriander on top at the end?

The chopped coriander is stirred into the hot kadhi before you turn off the heat. The only topping is the reserved fried pakodi, so skip raw coriander afterward.

Do I have to serve it with rice?

No, rice is a side. Serve it with steamed rice or cumin rice if you want it as kadhi chawal.

Sources