Turkish aşure scattered with pomegranate seeds, walnuts, and cinnamon
Prep8 hr
Cook1 hr 25 min
Serves6 servings
CuisineTurkish / Anatolian

Aşure Recipe: Turkey's Noah's Pudding of Wheat and Beans

How to make aşure, the sweet pudding of wheat and beans shared in Turkey, kept clear for the home kitchen: parboiling wheat berries and beans, when to add fruit, adjusting thickness, substitutes outside Turkey, storage, and how to serve it.

Total: 9 hr 25 minLevel: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 6

Soak the wheat and beans separately

8 hours

Wheat berries, dried chickpeas, and dried white beans soaking overnight in separate bowls
Soak the wheat and beans separately. They cook differently, so don't soak them in the same pot

Put the wheat berries, dried chickpeas, and dried white beans in separate bowls and pour in about 4 times their volume of water. On days the room is warm, put them in the refrigerator and let them absorb slowly overnight. In the morning, the beans are ready when they have swollen round and dent slightly when pressed hard with a finger. Discard the water and rinse the beans briefly.

STEP 22 / 6

Cook the wheat soft first

45 min

Wheat berries on low heat in a pot, white thickness beginning to appear, a step of aşure
Cook the wheat first. Building the wheat's thickness here makes the beans and fruit come together later

Put the soaked wheat berries and 1.25 quarts (1.2 L) of water in a heavy pot over medium heat. When it boils, lower to low and keep small bubbles rising from the bottom of the pot. If the water drops partway, add ½ cup (100 ml) at a time and cook for about 45 minutes. It is done when the surface of the grains has split, the cooking liquid is white and thick, and a line stays for a moment when you trace the bottom with a wooden spoon.

STEP 33 / 6

Add the beans and dried fruit

15 min

Soft-cooked chickpeas, white beans, and dried fruit being added to the pot of wheat
Parboil the beans before adding them. Cooking them from the start in the same pot as the wheat makes the firmness hard to match

In another pot, parboil the chickpeas and white beans in water to cover for 30 to 40 minutes until soft enough to crush with a finger. Put the parboiled beans, dried apricots, dried figs, raisins, and 1 g of salt into the wheat pot. Cook for 15 minutes over medium-low heat, keeping the temperature where the surface of the pot bubbles gently. Move on when the corners of the fruit have rounded and the beans have taken in the liquid and look glossy.

STEP 44 / 6

Adjust the thickness over low heat

12 min

Tracing the bottom of the pot with a wooden spoon, giving thickness to the wheat and bean liquid
Stir from the bottom over low heat. Settling the thickness before adding the sugar makes it less likely to burn

If there is little liquid, add 1¼ cups (300 ml) of water and lower to low heat. The bottom of the pot scorches easily, so cook for 12 minutes, stirring in big strokes from the bottom with a wooden spoon. Do not boil it too hard; keep it where small bubbles come up slowly on the surface. Stop when the liquid falls plumply from the spoon and the line on the bottom of the pot closes in about 2 seconds. If it is runny, cook 5 more minutes; if too heavy, add 3.5 tbsp (50 ml) of boiling water at a time.

STEP 55 / 6

Add the sugar and citrus aroma

8 min

Adding sugar, orange zest, and orange blossom water to the pot of aşure
Add the sugar last. Add the flower water after turning off the heat to keep its aroma

Add 4.5 oz (130 g) of granulated sugar and the orange zest and stir for 8 minutes over low heat. Once the sugar goes in it loosens for a moment, but the liquid comes back clear and glossy. To keep the pot from scorching, hold the heat at a small bubble of about 194°F (85 to 90°C). After turning off the heat, mix in 1 tsp of orange blossom water. The flower aroma is easily lost when boiled, so just letting it blend in the residual heat is enough.

STEP 66 / 6

Divide into bowls and finish

5 min

Cooked aşure divided into small bowls and finished with pomegranate and nuts
Finish after the surface has settled slightly. The color of pomegranate and nuts gives the festive look of a sweet to share

With the heat off, divide it into bowls while hot. Shake lightly so the surface is flat, and when a thin skin forms after about 10 minutes, scatter walnuts, hazelnuts or pistachios, pomegranate, and cinnamon. Decorating when the steam has settled rather than piping hot keeps the nuts from getting too damp and keeps the pomegranate's color from sinking.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes and notes
Wheat berries or hulled wheat 6.5 oz (180 g) If you have none, 5.5 oz (160 g) of coarse bulgur. Add bulgur late in the cooking
Dried chickpeas 2.75 oz (80 g) If canned, drained 6.5 oz (180 g)
Dried white beans 2.75 oz (80 g) If canned, drained 6.5 oz (180 g)
Water 2 quarts (1.6–2 L) For cooking. Separate plenty for soaking
Granulated sugar 4.5 oz (130 g) Lightly sweet. Up to 6 oz (170 g) for local-style sweetness
Dried apricots 2.5 oz (70 g) Chopped into 0.5 inches (1 cm) pieces
Dried figs 2 oz (60 g) Chopped into 0.5 inches (1 cm) pieces. The pop of the seeds becomes texture
Raisins 2 oz (60 g) Rinse quickly and drain
Orange zest 1/2 orange Avoid the white pith and cut thin. 20 g of candied orange peel also works
Orange blossom water 1 tsp Optional. If using, add after turning off the heat
Salt 1 g Tightens the sweetness
Walnuts 1.5 oz (40 g) Coarsely chopped
Hazelnuts or pistachios 1 oz (30 g) For finishing. Either one is fine
Pomegranate 2.75 oz (80 g) Leave out if you can't find it. Sour fruit suits it rather than strawberries
Ground cinnamon 1 tsp For finishing
0 / 0

Trace the bottom of the pot with a wooden spoon and the grains slowly close back in behind it. Aşure is a Turkish sweet grain pudding: wheat, beans, dried apricots, figs, raisins, and nuts cooked together in one pot until they loosen into each other, then scattered with pomegranate and cinnamon. It is eaten warm or chilled, and its sweetness is soft and fruity, never sticky. In Turkey it is made in the month of Muharram and shared with neighbors, so the pot always holds more than one household will eat.

About Aşure, Turkey's Noah's Pudding

In English aşure is written Ashure, or called Noah's pudding, and it is often told together with the legend of Noah's Ark. Unlike a flan, it is not set smooth. It is a spoonable pot of grains, beans, and fruit, and what sets it apart from other Middle Eastern sweets is the custom of making a large amount at home and handing it out to neighbors and relatives.

It is much more homey than syrup sweets like baklava and knafeh. It works as a small bowl after a meal or as a sweet porridge in the morning. If you have made Armenia's harissa or Bangladesh's haleem, the long, patient cooking of wheat will feel familiar.

Regional Versions of Aşure

Aşure changes from region to region. Fava beans, black-eyed peas, corn, pomegranate, and sesame all turn up. Some regions use rice with or in place of wheat, some sweeten with pekmez instead of sugar, and some add a little meat. For a first batch, stick to the sweet version with wheat, beans, fruit, and nuts; it is easier to shop for, and the taste is easier to get right. For another celebration porridge built on grain, see Kazakhstan's nauryz kozhe.

Ingredients

Ingredients for aşure: wheat, chickpeas, white beans, dried apricots, figs, raisins, pomegranate, and nuts laid out
The stars are wheat and beans. Fruit and nuts layer sweetness and aroma on later

This serves 6, or 8 in smaller bowls. If using dried beans, soak them the night before. Using canned beans greatly shortens the soaking and parboiling time.

Ingredients That Cause Hesitation When Shopping

With aşure, the result changes not with sugar or ordinary nuts but with wheat, dried beans, and the flower water. Treat as online candidates only what you can't gather at your local supermarket; easy-to-find fruit and sugar are fine from ordinary shopping.

If you cannot find wheat berries, using coarse bulgur makes it come together more easily as a home version. It softens faster than traditional wheat berries, so rather than cooking it from the start, it is easier to handle if you add it after building the wheat's thickness. Bulgur can be found at Middle Eastern or international grocers or from online sellers.

Chickpeas can be made from canned too, but reconstituting dried ones keeps the skins from breaking easily even in sweet wheat, and leaves aroma. They also go into hummus and falafel, so if you will keep cooking Middle Eastern food, a bag of dried chickpeas is worth having.

Orange blossom water is not required. But just 1 tsp switches it from "sweet bean porridge" to the aroma of a Middle Eastern sweet. It also goes into knafeh and baklava, so if you will keep making sweet Middle Eastern desserts, a bottle goes quickly.

Choosing Ingredients for Aşure

The base is hulled wheat, white beans, chickpeas, dried fruit, and sugar. Walnuts, hazelnuts, pomegranate, cinnamon, cloves, orange peel, and orange blossom water are layered on top, and the full list can run to more than 15 ingredients. On a first try, that many ingredients make the work harder than the taste is worth. Start with wheat, beans, dried fruit, nuts, and a citrus aroma.

It helps to know the role each one plays. Wheat brings "grains and thickness," beans bring "chew," dried fruit brings "sweet-sourness," and nuts bring "the final toastiness." Keep those four, and even with just a regular supermarket and online shopping you get the outline of aşure.

What to protect What can be substituted What is hard to substitute
The grain feel of the wheat Coarse bulgur if there are no wheat berries Rice alone weakens the aşure-like chew
Softness of the beans Rinsed canned beans if dried beans are hard to find Hard beans are difficult to fix afterward
Sweet-sourness of the fruit Ordinary supermarket dried apricots, figs, and raisins are fine Sugar alone makes the flavor flat
Aroma of the finish Cinnamon, walnuts, and pomegranate are enough Even a little orange blossom water changes the character
It uses wheat, so it contains gluten. If you use walnuts, hazelnuts, pistachios, or sesame for finishing, be careful of nut and sesame allergies. Check the label on dried fruit, as some is treated with sulfites.

Fixing Aşure Thickness and Sweetness

A pot and bowl comparing runny aşure with aşure thick enough that a spoon trail slowly closes
Aşure firms up as it cools. Don't make it too thick while hot

The most common failure is aşure that looks right while hot, then firms up too much in the refrigerator. Wheat and beans keep absorbing liquid as they cool. Stop cooking when it is a little thicker than drinking yogurt, and once chilled it will be easy to scoop with a spoon.

Condition Cause Fix
Runny, and the ingredients sink in the bowl Wheat undercooked, or too much water Add 5 minutes at a time over low heat. Stir the bottom and add sugar after thickness appears
Hard like rice cake after refrigeration Reduced too much while hot Stir in 2 tbsp of boiling water at a time. If the aroma is faint, add a little cinnamon
Only the beans are hard Not parboiled enough They hardly soften after sugar goes in. Next time, cook the beans first until they can be crushed with a finger
Sweetness is blurry Not enough salt or fruit acidity Add a pinch of salt, and increase the orange zest or pomegranate
Aroma is too strong Too much flower water Divide into bowls while warm and add more cinnamon and nuts to disperse the aroma

If you want it less sweet, resist cutting the sugar in half. The wheat and beans come forward too much, and it starts to taste like a sweet staple rather than a dessert. Make it with 4.5 oz (130 g) the first time and bring lightness with pomegranate and cinnamon at the finish.

Serving, Storing, and Varying Aşure

Serving Aşure

Warm aşure eats like a sweet breakfast porridge; chilled, it makes a small dessert after a meal. After a salty mercimek çorbası or a strongly herbal tabbouleh, a bowl of beans and wheat fits right in. It sits well beside other festive grain dishes, such as Kazakhstan's nauryz kozhe.

Storing Aşure

Storage containers for refrigeration and aşure divided into small bowls on the table
Aşure is easier to eat divided into small bowls. It firms up when refrigerated, so loosen it a little the next day

Aşure can be eaten the day you make it, but after half a day in the refrigerator the sweetness of the fruit moves into the wheat and the flavor rounds out. Divide it into small bowls before chilling, and the surface sets neatly and the bowls go straight to the table.

Storage method Guide How to bring it back when eating
Refrigerated 3 days As is, as a cold dessert. If hard, stir in 1 tbsp of boiling water
Reheating Until the next day Over low heat in a small pot. It scorches easily, so add a little water
Freezing Not recommended The texture of the wheat and beans tends to turn crumbly
Taking to a gathering Same day Add the nuts and pomegranate just before eating

Regional Variations at Home

Variation seen there How to include it at home Caution
Mixing rice into the wheat Add 2 tbsp of rice only when you have few wheat berries If rice becomes the star it drifts toward porridge
Sweetening with pekmez Mix in a little grape concentrate or dark brown sugar All dark brown sugar makes the color and aroma too strong
Adding corn Add just 3 tbsp of canned corn The sweetness drifts Western, so keep it small
Topping with pomegranate or sesame Prioritize pomegranate if you have it. Sesame up to 1 tsp Too much topping hides the flavor of the wheat

Frequently Asked Questions

I have no wheat berries. Can I make it with rice only?

Rice alone makes a sweet porridge, but it loses the chew of the wheat at the core of aşure. Coarse bulgur is closer. Bulgur breaks down quickly, so instead of cooking it for 45 minutes from the start, add it before step 4 and cook for 15 to 20 minutes.

Is it okay with canned chickpeas and white beans?

Yes. Drain them, rinse lightly, and add them in step 3. Canned beans are already soft and their skins tear with long cooking, so shorten step 3 to 10 minutes and stir gently.

Is orange blossom water required?

Orange zest alone gives enough aroma. Adding 1 tsp of orange blossom water brings the floral aftertaste of a Middle Eastern sweet, but too much tastes like perfume, so keep it to 1 tsp the first time.

Is it eaten warm or chilled?

Either way. Freshly made, the wheat aroma stands out; chilled, the sweetness of the dried fruit blends in. Eat it warm on the day and cold in a small bowl the next day, and you'll taste the difference.

I can't get pomegranate.

You can make it without. For acidity, add a little more orange zest at the finish, or use fewer raisins and more dried apricots. Strawberries and blueberries look festive but pull away from the grain character of aşure.

It's a dish made in large amounts. Is 6 servings okay?

In Turkey it is often made in a big pot and shared, but a large first batch makes the thickness hard to adjust. Learn the wheat thickness and bean softness with 6 servings, then double the ingredients the second time. Even doubled, use a heavy pot, because the bottom scorches easily.

Sources